Today on the Science Talk podcast, Noam Slonim of IBM Research speaks to Scientific American about an impressive feat of computer engineering: an AI-powered autonomous system that can engage in complex debate with humans over issues ranging from subsidizing preschool and the merit of space exploration to the pros and cons of genetic engineering.
In a new Nature paper, Slonim and his colleagues show that across 80 debate topics, Project Debater’s computational argument technology has performed very decently—with a human audience being the judge of that. “However, it is still somewhat inferior on average to the results obtained by expert human debaters,” Slonim says.
In a 2019 San Francisco showcase, the system went head-to-head with expert debater Harish Natarajan.
Beyond gaming, it’s rare to see humans and machines go against each other, let alone in an oratory competition.
Not unlike its human counterpart, the AI was given only 15 minutes to research the topic and prepare for the debate—rifling through thousands of gigabytes of information at record speed to form an opening statement and layer counterarguments that were later delivered through a robotic female voice, in fragments and with near perfect diction.
It couldn’t best Natarajan in San Francisco, but in a different debate, the system—co-led by Slonim and fellow IBM researcher Ranit Aharonov—has managed to change the stance of nine people in a debate on the use of telemedicine, essentially swaying the debate to its side and rebutting the argument of its opponent.
In other words, in this realm, humans still prevail.
But how do you build the architecture for a complex system like this? Is the AI capable of recognizing meaning or larger contexts in a debate? Can a system descended from Project Debater one day intervene in real-life social media arguments to quell misinformation or stir a debate in one direction or another, for better or worse? We answer these questions and more in the podcast.
COVID-19 Vaccine Ethics: Who Gets It First and Other Issues
How Your Homes and Buildings Affect You
African-Americans, Nature and Environmental Justice
How Nature Helps Body and Soul
The Messenger Is the Message
Air, Sea and Space: Ocean Health, Atmosphere Insights and Black Holes
Science on the Hill: Calculating Climate
Your Brain, Free Will and the Law
No, No Nobel: How to Lose the Prize
Galileo's Fight against Science Denial
Where Is Everybody Else in the Universe?
Why Exercise Is So Good For You
COVID-19: What the Autopsies Reveal
COVID-19: The Need for Secure Labs--and Their Risks
Flat Earthers: What They Believe and Why
COVID-19: Predicting the Path and Analyzing Immunity
COVID-19: How and Why the Virus Spreads Quickly
COVID-19: The Wildlife Trade and Human Disease
David Quammen: How Animal Infections Spill Over to Humans
COVID-19: Dealing with Social Distancing
Create your
podcast in
minutes
It is Free
Science, Quickly
60-Second Earth
60-Second Space
60-Second Health
60-Second Tech