Canadian police have cautioned citizens against sharing videos of 'porch pirates' – individuals stealing packages from porches – as it might infringe on the thieves' privacy rights. This unusual warning has sparked widespread outrage and debate, particularly in Quebec. The police's stance stems from a legal perspective that emphasizes the presumption of innocence and privacy rights, even for individuals caught in the act of stealing on home security footage. Critics argue this approach excessively protects criminals at the expense of law-abiding citizens. They contend that public exposure via social media could deter such thefts, especially as law enforcement resources are strained. The debate highlights a growing tension between public safety, individual rights, and the effectiveness of community-based crime prevention.