podbean
  • Discover
  • Podcast Features

    Your all-in-one podcasting solution.

    Podcast App

    The best podcast player & podcast app.

  • Livestream

    High-performing audio live, without limits.

    Podcast Studio

    Easy-to-use audio recorder app.

  • PodAds

    Dynamic Ad Insertion for podcasts.

  • Premium

    Convert listeners into buyers anywhere, anytime
    with the convenience of Podbean Premium.

    Patron

    The seamless way for fans to support you directly
    from your podcast.

  • Ad Marketplace

    Join Ad Marketplace to earn money
    through sponsorship on your podcast.

  •  
  • All Arts Business Comedy Education
  • Fiction Government Health & Fitness History Kids & Family
  • Leisure Music News Religion & Spirituality Science
  • Society & Culture Sports Technology True Crime TV & Film
  • Live
  • Log in
  • Start your podcast for free
  • Podcasting
    • Podcast Features
    • Live Stream
    • PodAds
    • Podcast App
    • Podcast Studio
  • Monetization
    • Premium
    • Patron
    • Ad Marketplace
  • Enterprise
  • Pricing
  • Discover
  • Log in
    Sign up free
The Black Goat

The Black Goat

Science

Letting Loose Your Inner Reviewer Two

Letting Loose Your Inner Reviewer Two

2019-12-12
iOS Android Share
Peer review is a major part of how science works today. In this episode we talk about how we approach doing peer reviews. How do you distinguish between differences in approach or preference - "I...

Peer review is a major part of how science works today. In this episode we talk about how we approach doing peer reviews. How do you distinguish between differences in approach or preference - "I would have done it a different way" - versus things that you should treat as objections? How much weight do you put on different considerations - the importance of the research question, the novelty, the theory, the methods, the results, and other factors? What's your actual process - do you read front-to-back, or jump around? How much do you edit and wordsmith your reviews? When there are appendices, supplements, open code and materials, and preregistrations, which things do you read and how do you factor them in? How do you think about your potential biases and how to mitigate them? Plus: We answer a letter about deciding whether to pursue a postdoc versus other options.

The Black Goat is hosted by Sanjay Srivastava, Alexa Tullett, and Simine Vazire. Find us on the web at www.theblackgoatpodcast.com, on Twitter at @blackgoatpod, on Facebook at facebook.com/blackgoatpod/, and on instagram at @blackgoatpod. You can email us at letters@theblackgoatpodcast.com. You can subscribe to us on iTunes or Stitcher.

Our theme music is Peak Beak by Doctor Turtle, available on freemusicarchive.org under a Creative Commons noncommercial attribution license. Our logo was created by Jude Weaver.

This is episode 71. It was recorded on December 6, 2019.

view more

More Episodes

You Took the Words Right Out of My Mouth

2020-10-30 4.9k

They Give You This, But You Pay For That

2020-09-23 4.3k

An Award-Winning Episode

2020-09-09 3.1k

Contact Sport

2020-08-26 3.4k

Does Not Compute

2020-08-13 3.5k

Objective Unknown

2020-07-29 3.5k

The Impending Fall of Academia

2020-07-15 3.9k

Inexact Science

2020-04-30 5.4k

COVID Operations

2020-04-15 3.5k

Joe Public, Will You Marry Me?

2020-04-01 3.5k

Just Be Cause

2020-03-21 4.0k

Auxiliary Turtles All the Way Down

2020-02-12 5.2k

The Expertise of Death

2020-01-29 4.5k

Going Off the Record

2020-01-17 4.2k

The Year 2019 in Review

2019-12-26 4.3k

Doctorpiece Theater

2019-11-29 4.2k

The Last Straw

2019-11-13 4.0k

Talk the Talk

2019-10-30 4.4k

Everybody Act Normal

2019-10-16 4.4k
  • ←
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • →
0123456789101112131416171819

Get this podcast on your
phone, FREE

You may also like

Sasquatch Chronicles

Sasquatch Chronicles

26.1k 196.3k
The Best of Coast to Coast AM

The Best of Coast to Coast AM

19.0k 270.9k
Hidden Brain

Hidden Brain

40.9k 927.6k
Stuff To Blow Your Mind

Stuff To Blow Your Mind

39.7k 551.7k
Short Wave

Short Wave

2.8k 84.9k
  • Podcast Services
    • Podcast Features
    • Pricing
    • Enterprise Solution
    • Private Podcast
    • The Podcast App
    • Live Stream
    • Audio Recorder
  •  
    • Podcast Hosting
    • Create a Podcast
    • Video Podcast
    • Podcast Stats
    • Start Podcasting
    • Switch to Podbean
    • Submit your podcast
  •  
    • Education Podcast
    • Church Podcast
    • Nonprofit Podcast
    • Get Sermons Online
    • Free Audiobooks
    • Start Radio Talk Show
    • How to start a podcast
  • MONETIZATION
    • Premium Podcast
    • Podcast Advertising
    • Patron Program
  • Support
    • Email Us
    • Support Center
    • Free Webinars
    • Developers
    • Podbean Plugins
    • Resources
  • Podbean
    • About Us
    • Affiliate Program
    • Badges
    • Terms of Use
    • Privacy Policy
    • Podbean Blog

Copyright © 2006-2021 Podbean.com