Let me help you. Chances are that one yungerman who said that fantastic chabura who seemed to reach the depths probably missed the boat if he didn’t know a substantial portion of shas and rishonim.

a

How about rabbi ms Shapiro that said over from the brisker rov you want us to break our heads over that the correct way is iyun kal. Gemora rashi tosafos rosh. Ty.

Did rabbi greineman cite a source for his opinion?

Wonderful hashkafa from rabbi ribner, but one question: has the rabbi ever read the letters from the chief rosh Yeshiva of the past generation Rav Shach where he writes of you are not baki in shas first your iyun is worthless?

a

R Gershon Very impressed with the clearness. Sounds like you have a better דעת תורה then the professionalsדעת תורה. I am a good friend of yours and you know me well

Gevaldik