Comments (117)

To leave or reply comments, please download free Podbean iOS App or Android App.

Guilty of Jane Rimmer and Ciara Glennon. Not Guilty of Sarah Spiers.

@hodgy : I’ve listened to every episode as well, and agree that if I was a juror, I’d be finding him guilty. However I definitely think he’s going to be found not guilty of Sarah Spiers murder, there are too many unanswered questions. I think the DNA sinks him with the other two, but I wouldn’t be shocked if the defence has raised enough reasonable doubt. If this case was in America, he’d walk free for sure.
11 hours ago reply 0

Wheres the bonus episodes. Ive been waiting weeks on end !

1 months ago reply 0

Yeah he came across to me as a bit dull, boring, and very normal, which is I guess the scary bit. And of course knowing what we know now. He was lying through his back teeth.

@hodgy : Yeah mate, I couldn’t wait to hear his whole police interview. He’s an interesting character... Completely full of shit, but well rehearsed at denying tough questions.
3 months ago reply 1

Yeah mate, I couldn’t wait to hear his whole police interview. He’s an interesting character... Completely full of shit, but well rehearsed at denying tough questions.

@john : Did you by any chance listen to the audio on the WA supreme court website? His police interviews were interesting, and gave a little insight into the man.
3 months ago reply 1

Did you by any chance listen to the audio on the WA supreme court website? His police interviews were interesting, and gave a little insight into the man.

@hodgy : Yeah mate.. couldn’t agree more.
3 months ago reply 1

Yeah mate.. couldn’t agree more.

@john : Yes I think your right. Unless justice hall is of the opinion beyond reasonable doubt that the same perpetrator committed all 3 murders. But I'm not convinced the prosecution have done enough to prove that.
3 months ago reply 1

Yes I think your right. Unless justice hall is of the opinion beyond reasonable doubt that the same perpetrator committed all 3 murders. But I'm not convinced the prosecution have done enough to prove that.

@hodgy : I’ve listened to every episode as well, and agree that if I was a juror, I’d be finding him guilty. However I definitely think he’s going to be found not guilty of Sarah Spiers murder, there are too many unanswered questions. I think the DNA sinks him with the other two, but I wouldn’t be shocked if the defence has raised enough reasonable doubt. If this case was in America, he’d walk free for sure.
3 months ago reply 1

I’ve listened to every episode as well, and agree that if I was a juror, I’d be finding him guilty. However I definitely think he’s going to be found not guilty of Sarah Spiers murder, there are too many unanswered questions. I think the DNA sinks him with the other two, but I wouldn’t be shocked if the defence has raised enough reasonable doubt. If this case was in America, he’d walk free for sure.

@john : Having listened to this entire podcast now. I'm pretty sure if I was a juror I'd be delivering a guilty verdict.
3 months ago reply 1

Having listened to this entire podcast now. I'm pretty sure if I was a juror I'd be delivering a guilty verdict.

3 months ago reply 2

Getting to the business end now... the reasonable doubt genie is still sticking his head up. It will be interesting to see how the Defence finishes up.

3 months ago reply 1

far out He denies it all and refuses to take the stand. But quite happy to talk about himself when asked about private life etc. Everything points to him, he needs to fess up. Tricia- the podcast folks are very very good. They werent laughing at inappropriate times- they were laughing at how ridiculous BRE is. His defence has given up. Cmon Carmel Barbagallo and put a murdering brutal rapist where he belongs !

4 months ago reply 3

Has the case of kerry turner every been looked at in relation to Edwards. She was found deceased in the bush, was early 90’s and not too far from the area he lived.

4 months ago reply 0

Loved listening to the podcast but sometimes you all laughed at inappropriate times I don’t think there’s anything to laugh about with this case at all apart from that it was great

4 months ago reply 0

🤦🏼‍♀️🤦🏼‍♀️🤦🏼‍♀️ it’s a podcast that follows the trial

@Megan : Hiya, 🧡 your podcast but ... how many more episodes on this forensic evidence? 🤨
4 months ago reply 0

I love the enthusiasm, but no. Stringing random facts together proves nothing and accomplishes fuck all. Stick to the facts.

@tranceaddictbarbie75 : @Hodgy ok. I think hes def done in Julie Cutler
5 months ago reply 2

Hiya, 🧡 your podcast but ... how many more episodes on this forensic evidence? 🤨

5 months ago reply 1

@Hodgy ok. I think hes def done in Julie Cutler

5 months ago reply 0