On this episode the hosts get drunk and dig into the 1949–1950 Necedah apparitions reported by Mary Ann Van Hoof: glowing crucifixes, a blue mist that formed into a lady, huge rural crowds, claims of a "miracle of the sun," apocalyptic messages, and a bishopal investigation that declared the events false.
Between jokes and skepticism the crew explores how the sightings spawned a break with the Catholic Church, an independent shrine and strange iconography, and they debate whether it was genuine faith, a psychological coping mechanism, or mass hysteria.