EP 25 The Prophet of Death: Herbert Mullin — Santa Cruz’s Darkest Season | Creepy Coffees Podcast

Every ghost story deserves a good cup of coffee. ☕️ Tonight we dive into the chilling case of Herbert Mullin, the self-styled “prophet” who believed human sacrifice could stop California earthquakes. This is Santa Cruz at its most haunted—where psychosis, fear, and failure of systems collided.

What’s inside:
• Early years, grief, and the first cracks in reality
• The “divine mission” and voices that demanded blood
• A four-month killing spree across Santa Cruz County
• Arrest, trial, and the question: evil or untreated illness?
• Legacy, lessons, and how communities heal

Sponsors & Shout-outs:
Huge thanks to our sponsors for keeping the mugs full and the mics hot.
Special shout-out to Care and the crew at Dutch Bros in Flagstaff, AZ—thanks for always being happy to see us and fueling our late-night edits!

Mental Health Resources:
If you or someone you know is struggling with mental illness, please reach out. In the U.S., call or text 988 for the Suicide & Crisis Lifeline. You’re not alone.

Connect & Support:
• Subscribe for more creepy, caffeinated stories
• Rate & review—it helps others find the show
• Merch & show notes: CreepyCoffees.com
• Email: Contact@CreepyCoffees.com