🦲The 3 Personalities of Karen Horney Feminist Psychoanalyst

Read More at https://gettherapybirmingham.com/blog/

 

 

Karen Horney was a German psychoanalyst. Her career came into prominence in the nineteen
twenties when she formed theories on human attachment and neurosis that split from Freud’s
key ideas. Horney’s theory of personality development and individuation are still highly relevant
to modern theories of personality, attachment psychology and psychological trauma. Even
though she is not well remembered, her work is as relevant as it was at the turn of the century.
Applying her theories to my work with patients and to my own life has been an integral piece of
my own personal and professional development. This article is part one of four in a series
explaining Horney’s theories.

At the time of this writing my daughter is two. Sometimes when my wife and I relax slightly in
public, she will get a glimmer in her eye and, starting to giggle, run away from us. While we will
yell for her to stop, she will cackle drunk with her new found power, as she runs away into a
crowd of strangers or into oncoming traffic. When we take her to school or to meet new people
she wraps herself around my wife’s leg, pressing her cheek into my wife’s calf, and refuses to
Speak.

Two year old children cannot understand moderation or limitation. They demand to have “more
food” even when their plate is overflowing. Minutes later they will refuse to eat another bite
because they are “full”. They cannot understand shades of gray. They refuse to believe that
they need a nap until their eyes are closing. People are either all “bad guys” or all “good guys”.
Individual children live in a world of extremes with tunnel vision on their immediate present
desires and realities.

Infants do not understand that they are separate creatures from their mother. The first
traumatic event in an infant’s life is the separation from the mother as the infant
becomes a toddler. Infants are connected to the mother for so much of their post birth
experience. In order to soothe infants we try to make them feel as though they are still in the
womb. We swaddle infants, keep them warm, and play white noise. The mother is both their
source of physical comfort and nourishment. So much of the infant’s conscious experience is
centered on its connection to its mother, that it makes sense that infants would lack the ability to
understand what they are outside of the central reality of their experience.

For the nine months in the womb an infant is physically and psychologically dependent on its
mother. It takes at least one and a half years after being born for infants to begin to piece
together that they will have to eventually become something separate from their mother.
Because infants cannot understand their existence without their mother, this means that when
they are inevitably forced to separate from their mother, infants feel like their existence is under
threat. The necessary task of the mother is to separate the child from herself into itself. Yet, this
feels to the child like it is being obliterated. This is often the first major trauma of a child’s life.

Karen Horney’s theory of personality and neurosis is built on examining its effect on an infant’s
development. When toddlers begin to be separated from their mothers they experience
moments where they, like my daughter, think they are God and can run through traffic. They are
completely independant, completely free, can do things “by themself”, and will never need
supervision or approval from parents again. They quickly alternate into periods of abject terror
where they are horrified with their agency as an independent being and, often wrapping
themselves around her leg, attempt to remerge with their mother.

The distinction between infant and toddler is between a creature that can not live independently
and a creature that sometimes thinks it can. Toddlers alternate between rejecting all authority to
become a god and trying to crawl back into the womb in order to forget they exist. Our ego is
what allows us to navigate the overwhelming forces of the unconscious. The ego allows us to
accept both our autonomy and reconcile our own ultimate insignificance. Toddlers are just
beginning to develop an ego that will synthesize these competing, and contradictory realities.
As a trauma therapist I use Horney’s theories constantly. The connection between the way that
our parents give us attention and the way we learn to get attention from others in later life is
endlessly relevant in many types of therapy, especially work with trauma. In Horney’s theory of
neurosis, the way that a child individuates from their mother determines their coping style and
predicts many of the psychological issues they may develop in later life.

Moving Towards People

Karen Horney was a German psychoanalyst. Her career came into prominence in the nineteen
twenties when she formed theories on human attachment and neurosis that split from Freud’s
key ideas. Horney’s theory of personality development and individuation are still highly relevant
to modern theories of personality, attachment psychology and psychological trauma.
Horney observed that children deploy three different coping styles during the time they are
individuating from the mother. Ideally children learn mastery in the three different styles. In
imperfect situations infants become over dependent in one style and form a neurotic and rigid
personality style. This second part of a four part article will explore the moving towards people
personality style.

The first coping strategy that children will attempt in order to retain the connection with the
mother during individuation is to ask for help Horney called this stage moving towards people.
As infants we cry in order to make our mothers come running to our aid. If our mother’s continue
to come running to our aid for the rest of childhood however, this can impair our development as
we fail to learn to solve our own problems internally or assert ourselves. In extreme cases
where mothers will not separate from a child to allow room for experimentation with assertive

aggression or self soothing behavior the child becomes neurotic and co-dependant in the
moving towards people style.
People and characters with this level of impairment see the entire world in terms of their mother
and never learn to make their own judgements or form their own values. What would mother
think of this? That is against mother’s rules. Another force like a charismatic leader, romantic
partner or social identity may replace the actual mother at some point, but the inability to be a
separate person will remain. Persons over dependent on another person or group’s ego have
no ability to self soothe without the warm glow of the surrogate mother’s approval and ability to
define rules and worth.

Horney calls this neurosis the need for affection and approval. The sense of self in people with
this personality type is incredibly diffuse as they are not able to watch others withdraw their
approval even for good reason. The psychologist Albert Ellis used to tell his patients that “It is
pathological to want to be liked by everybody all the time”. I often tell mine that “There are times
when the loving or the honest thing to do is to piss someone off”. When we cannot stand to see
our standards judged by other people it means that we cannot have a stable sense of self with
authentic standards for self worth.

This need often manifests as a form of codependency in relationships or friendships as people
try to replace the stabilizing presence of a controlling caregiver with a different set of rules and
boundaries. We learn to tolerate the anxiety of not knowing what to do and being forced to
choose early in life. When we have not been allowed to adapt to making small choices over the
life course we decompensate in the face of larger overwhelming choices about our life and
Identity.

In therapy I encounter patients who have had a controlling caregiver, and a corresponding
inability to develop their own sense of identity. I start by asking them simple questions about
who they are. Patients with an underdeveloped sense of personal identity will often have no
idea what their basic preferences and beliefs are. Often they will have found an abusive partner
or a rigid social, political, or religious group to fill up the “blank” spaces in their identity with. In
healthy partnerships we are allowed to maintain our own sense of identity while still participating
in a group affiliation or romantic partnership.

I always frame the therapy with these patients as an exciting adventure that we are going on
together. We are going to discover who the patient is and who they want to become. Patients of
this coping style often will try and figure out what the therapist wants them to do and what the
“new rules” that the therapist has for their life are. Their primary fear is that they will do
something “wrong” and don't know what the “right” answers are to their life questions. I tell
patients that “You are the only best expert in how to be you”.

While the freedom and gray area of this kind of personality development therapy is initially
terrifying to patients, eventually this style of therapy becomes exhilarating as patients reconnect
to a long absent sense of self. Even though patients present to therapy blank and indifferent about their, often abusive and traumatic history, they will start to recognize moments in the past
when they had a strong emotion or a preference that was dismissed by a caregiver or a partner.
“I was so angry that my clothes were picked out for me every day”. “I was told that good
christians don’t go to prom”.

Not all people in the moving towards people neurotic type will use a partner to try and
complete their functioning. Oftentimes I have patients with social and intellectual gifts that use
admiration, fame or envy in order to move towards people. Many people seek fame or attention,
but those with a moving towards people neurosis will not be able to function without
admiration of others. These patients are not able to determine the value or morality of their
behavior without group approval.

Moving Against People

Karen Horney was a German psychoanalyst. Her career came into prominence in the nineteen
twenties when she formed theories on human attachment and neurosis that split from Freud’s
key ideas. Horney’s theory of personality development and individuation are still highly relevant
to modern theories of personality, attachment psychology and psychological trauma. This third
part of a four part article will explore the moving against people personality style.

In Horney’s theory of individuation, the individuating child will settle into one of three different
personality styles based on what allows it to successfully reclaim its parent’s attention. The first style that children try is the moving towards people style. This is most familiar to the child since this is the style they are accustomed to using in infancy. If this asking for attention and attempting to be close to the mother through affection fail, the child will next try aggression in order to force it’s caregiver to give it what it wants. If only aggression is effective the child will
settle firmly into a moving against people personality style.

People in the moving against people personality style had sporadic or unpredictable affection
offered to them as children. They came from environments that were hostile or uncaring and
handled the fundamental insecurity that these environments engendered by becoming
aggressive. They never had the option of asking for the basic attention children need and
instead learned to demand attention. Caregivers were neglectful and unresponsive until these
fought for the little affection or attention available in their home.

This reality in their family of origin colors these patient’s interpersonal style and assumptions
about the world. These assumptions about others and the world are immediately recognizable in
the first few minutes of the first therapy session when a patient in the moving against people
personality style presents to therapy. Patients in the moving against people personality style are not likely to come to therapy and do not usually present to therapy until they are in crisis or
are facing significant personal or professional losses due to their rigidity.

Just as patients in the moving towards people personality type often have anger turned off,
patients in the moving against people personality type are often out of touch with their ability
to feel hurt or vulnerable. To ward this feeling off patients in theis personality style develop a
“don’t mess with me” defensive posture. They may use wit as a weapon becoming acerbically
funny. They maybe overly macho or simply act like they don’t care what anyone thinks.

Most often patients who are neurotic in the moving against people personality style are highly
competitive and motivated to dominate athletics, group functions and professional environments. Patients in this style are often high achievers when they are skilled. They are
seen as invulnerable at work but often feel hollow in personal spheres. They are unable to
understand the point of life without comparison and competition. Patients often present to
therapy in middle age when there is “nothing else left to win”.

Moving Away From People

Karen Horney was a German psychoanalyst. Her career came into prominence in the nineteen
twenties when she formed theories on human attachment and neurosis that split from Freud’s
key ideas. Horney’s theory of personality development and individuation are still highly relevant
to modern theories of personality, attachment psychology and psychological trauma.

Horney observed that children deploy three different coping styles during the time they are
individuating from the mother. Ideally children learn mastery in the three different styles. In
imperfect situations infants become over dependent in one style and form a neurotic and rigid
personality style. This second part of a four part article will explore the moving away from
people personality style. 

Horney’s three neurotic personality styles can most simply be understood as dependency (moving towards people), Aggression (moving against people) and resignation (moving away from people). The resigned type is the result of the developing child discovering that they are unable to get the attention of the parent either through asking for attention or demanding it. The child then retreats into an innerworld where it creates its own systems of psychological reward through creativity and self expansion.

If you are a writer or a psychotherapist it is highly likely that you are strongly developed in this
area even if you are not quite a neurotic! The ability to move into your head and create your own
rules and concepts for life is a useful skill, but not one we learn from asking or demanding
attention from our parents. These personality types are more able to see through the arbitrary
nature of the rules or traditions in a society, and have less attachment to the cultural rules.

Unless these children develop ways of communicating these inner worlds they can seem
“spacey” or “lost in their thoughts”. All of the neuroses that Horeney observes can be understood as the limiting conditions that a person with insecure attachment has for being safe. The dependent type needs others to feel safe, while the aggressive type needs control. A person in the “moving away from people” neurotic type only feels safe when some inner condition of solitude or independance has been fulfilled. This ultimate value of independence can present in several ways. Some want to be invisible, living an unassuming and private life. Sometimes the fixation on independence manifests and living off the land, being wealthy, and sometimes as being emotionally independent. Patients in this style may emulate, Jay Gatsby, Jeremiah Johnson or John Wayne.

The moving away from people’s personality type is not comfortable unless they are absolutely
independent in some special area. While the moving towards people type needs people in order
to function, and the moving against people personality type needs people in order to become
dominant, the moving away from people type feels unsafe if it needs people for anything
substantial. This does not mean that they are unsuccessful socially, only that they are
uncomfortable with relying on social or emotional ties to others in order to feel stable. This type
failed to maintain a connection with their mother through either dependence seeking or
aggressive behaviors. 

They learned to soothe themselves and learned their own coping skills.
This process of learning to regulate ones own emotions as a child without assistance leads
children into their own head where they develop a large and elaborate inner world. Children
become less interested or even aware of external realities like norms, socially, or practical
tasks. Instead of learning to manage their feelings they become fascinated with them. 

Moving away from people personality type patients have a unique knack for encoding their beliefs, personality and opinions into artistic creations because they crave the recognition and
understanding that was denied them by their caregivers as children. Art, humor, fashion,
business even, is a way of communicating something about the hidden self to others.

 

Website: https://gettherapybirmingham.com/
Check out the youtube: https://youtube.com/@GetTherapyBirminghamPodcast Website: https://gettherapybirmingham.podbean.com/
Podcast Feed: https://feed.podbean.com/GetTherapyBirmingham/feed.xml

Taproot Therapy Collective
2025 Shady Crest Drive | Hoover, Alabama 35216
Phone: (205) 598-6471
Fax: (205) 634-3647
Email: Admin@GetTherapyBirmingham.com

The resources, videos and podcasts on our site and social media are no substitute for mental health treatment. Please find a qualified mental health provider and contact emergency services in your area in the event of an emergency to a provider in your area. Our number and email are only for scheduling at Taproot Therapy Collective are not monitored consistently and not a reliable resource for emergency services.