In January 2023, the UK's Investigatory Powers Tribunal handed down a landmark judgment. The Tribunal held that there were “very serious failings” at the highest levels of MI5 - the UK's domestic intelligence agency - to comply with privacy safeguards from as early as 2014, and that successive Home Secretaries did not to enquire into or resolve these long-standing rule-breaking despite obvious red flags.
In this episode, we talk to Meg Goulding, a lawyer at the UK-based campaigning organisation, Liberty, who was a solicitor instructed on the case, and Nour Haidar, a lawyer and member of the legal team at PI to discuss what this ruling actually means for the ongoing fight against mass surveillance.
The way our data was handled by MI5 amounts to a significant intrusion into potentially millions of people’s fundamental right to privacy. This case was a critical mechanism of holding MI5 accountable for failing to handle the data they hold in a lawful manner. Agencies tasked with protecting national security process huge amounts of sensitive information. Due to the nature of their work, their operations can’t be subjected to the same levels of scrutiny and transparency that we can demand of other government institutions, yet they are not above the law. That is why this case is so important: it is one of the only tools we have to ensure that our right to privacy is respected by the UK intelligence agencies.
Links
- PI's Case page for Liberty and PI v Security Service and Secretary of State for the Home Department IPT/20/01/CH
- PI's Q&A explaining the judgment
- Liberty's case page
- PI's Long-read explaining arguments in the case, including key disclosure
- Home Secretary statement "as compliant as possible"
A letter from the Russian government: Defending encryption in Court
What is Encryption? Codes, Keys, and Hashes
GPS tracking of migrants in the UK: Performative cruelty and dodgy tech
Good News: Things you might have missed in 2023
Generative AI: Our hot takes on deep fakes
No Competition: Big Tech, Big Problems
Tech Assisted Abuse: How smart devices can facilitate abuse
10 years since Snowden: Legacy, Law, and Litigation
GPS tracking migrants in the UK: Who profits?
Election Observation: Data, Elections and a trip to Kenya
Protecting the protectors: a case from Colombia
Producing Real Change: Our 2022
How to Investigate Digital Forensics: Speaking to the UK's Former Forensics Regulator
Corporate Power with Cory Doctorow
EdTech needs Schooling
Got PimEyes on you
Maternal Health and Family Planning in the Middle East: Gender and Power
Talking to People about Privacy
The EU, the Sahel and the Externalisation of Surveillance
Create your
podcast in
minutes
It is Free
Insight Story: Tech Trends Unpacked
Zero-Shot
Fast Forward by Tomorrow Unlocked: Tech past, tech future
Black Wolf Feed (Chapo Premium Feed Bootleg)
Bannon`s War Room