Who’s the best? Phillies or Mets?

2026-01-30

Download

The Phillies smoked the Mets in the NL East last year, winning the division by 13 games. But the Mets won the offseason, especially when they stunned the Phils and signed Bo Bichette. So, who’s better? We go position by position through the Phillies and Mets lineups, including the rotation and bullpen: Catcher: Francisco Alvarez vs. J.T. Realmuto First base: Jorge Polanco vs. Bryce Harper Second base: Marcus Semien vs. Bryson Stott Third base: Bo Bichette vs. Alec Bohm Shortstop: Francisco Lindor v...

The Phillies smoked the Mets in the NL East last year, winning the division by 13 games. But the Mets won the offseason, especially when they stunned the Phils and signed Bo Bichette.

So, who’s better?

We go position by position through the Phillies and Mets lineups, including the rotation and bullpen:

Catcher: Francisco Alvarez vs. J.T. Realmuto
First base: Jorge Polanco vs. Bryce Harper
Second base: Marcus Semien vs. Bryson Stott
Third base: Bo Bichette vs. Alec Bohm
Shortstop: Francisco Lindor vs. Trea Turner
Left field: Carson Begne/Tyrone Taylor vs. Brandon Marsh/Otto Kemp
Center field: Luis Robert Jr vs. Justin Crawford
Right field: Juan Soto vs. Adolis García

RIP Dan McQuade. A great Philadelphian, and a great writer who loved Philly. This is one of his best: How Far Did Rocky Go in His Training in Rocky II?

Love the show? Get Phillies Show merchandise at ThePhilliesShowShop.com!

@The Phillies Show Subscribe to the show on YouTube and follow us on social media!

@Foul Territory We’re part of the Foul Territory Network. Follow FT and find more shows, including Fair Territory!

If you like The Phillies Show, subscribe and give us a five-star review!

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Comments (3)