In Part 1 of our three-part series, we begin where most people first encountered this case: the headlines.This episode breaks down what happened, what Jonathan Gerlach was charged with, and why this case immediately drew national attention. We move carefully through the facts; separating confirmed information from speculation, before briefly pulling back the curtain on what we currently know about his personal life and online presence, setting the stage for deeper analysis in the episodes to come.What...
In Part 1 of our three-part series, we begin where most people first encountered this case: the headlines.This episode breaks down what happened, what Jonathan Gerlach was charged with, and why this case immediately drew national attention. We move carefully through the facts; separating confirmed information from speculation, before briefly pulling back the curtain on what we currently know about his personal life and online presence, setting the stage for deeper analysis in the episodes to come.
What we cover in Part 1:- Who Jonathan Gerlach is and why his name suddenly appeared everywhere
- The criminal charges filed against him and what those charges actually mean
- A timeline of how the story broke and why it escalated so quickly
- What was publicly known vs. what was assumed early on
⚠️ Content AdvisoryThis episode includes discussion of:- Grave desecration
- Human remains
- Ethical and legal violations
Details are discussed factually and without graphic description, with a focus on accountability and respect for the dead.
Come back for parts 2 and 3!Part 2: We trace how the investigation unfolded behind the scenes (thus far); what law enforcement could confirm, what remained unknown, and how silence was quickly filled by speculation. We separate documented evidence from public assumption, unpacking how screenshots, posts, and secondhand claims took on the weight of truth. We also confront why unverified details spread so easily, the ethical danger of online sleuthing when human remains are involved, and how noise, when left unchecked, can drown out victims, distort timelines, and quietly erode accountability.
Part 3: The historical and investigative significance of Mount Moriah Cemetery, how investigators narrowed their focus, and what the next steps are in this case in terms of identifying and contacting loved ones who were affected by this heinous crime.
Until next time, stay inside, stay alive.
References13WHAM. (2026). Ephrata man Jonathan Gerlach admits to selling human remains stolen from Pennsylvania cemetery. https://13wham.com/news/nation-world/ephrata-man-jonathan-gerlach-admits-to-selling-human-remains-stolen-from-pa-cemetery-search-warrant-delaware-county-philadelphia-mount-moriah-cemetery-lancaster-pennsylvania-skulls-skeletons-pa
Courthouse News Service. (2026). Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Jonathan Gerlach: Corpse theft and desecration cemetery docket [Court document]. https://www.courthousenews.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/pennsylvania-v-jonathan-gerlach-corpse-theft-desecration-cemetery-docket.pdf
LancasterOnline. (2026a). A look at investigation of human remains thefts linked to Ephrata suspect: Full coverage. https://lancasteronline.com/news/local/a-look-at-investigation-of-human-remains-thefts-linked-to-ephrata-suspect-full-coverage/collection_12941079-68a2-4c90-a05f-e00d075c3ae5.html
LancasterOnline. (2026b). PA Attorney General’s Office investigating if Ephrata man stole bodies from Luzerne County. https://lancasteronline.com/news/local/pa-attorney-generals-office-investigating-if-ephrata-man-stole-bodies-from-luzerne-county/article_3601b4ff-7eaf-44c0-b01f-c4204b5ac266.html
LancasterOnline. (2026c). Ephrata man charged in cemetery thefts linked to man going to prison in human remains case. https://lancasteronline.com/news/local/ephrata-man-charged-in-cemetery-thefts-linked-to-man-going-to-prison-in-human-remains/article_0faa53fc-d832-4dc8-ae61-a98c62d9e5ce.html
New York Post. (2026, January 10). Police find “horror movie” of stolen bones in alleged grave robber’s home. https://nypost.com/2026/01/10/us-news/police-find-horror-movie-of-stolen-bones-in-alleged-graverobbers-home/
YouTube. (2026). News coverage of Jonathan Gerlach investigation [Video]. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vspfw6cO4ok
