Why is a simple treatment not reaching children who need it?
Neeraj Sood, professor in the Price School of Public Policy at the University of Southern California, explores this preventable problem.
Neeraj is a professor at the USC Price School of Public Policy with joint appointments at the USC Keck School of Medicine and USC Marshall School of Business. He is a senior fellow at the USC Schaeffer Center whose research focuses on economic epidemiology, infectious diseases, pharmaceutical markets, health insurance, economics of innovation, and global health.
Why a Simple Treatment Isn’t Reaching Children Who Need It https://academicminute.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/04/05-02-24-USC-Why-a-simple-treatment-isnt-reaching-children-who-need-it.mp3Every year, nearly half a million children lose their lives to diarrhea globally—a tragedy that is largely preventable with a low-cost and widely available treatment known as oral rehydration salts, or ORS.
Most providers in developing countries know that ORS is highly effective at treating diarrhea, yet few prescribe it. We wanted to find out why.
We looked at three leading explanations why doctors might not recommend ORS in India, which has the most cases of child diarrhea in the world.
The first explanation was that ORS is out of stock because it is less profitable than other treatments, like antibiotics. The next explores whether doctors have financial incentives and earn more by prescribing antibiotics, even though it is ineffective for viral diarrhea. Lastly, we wanted to look at patient preferences, specifically whether doctors assume patients don’t want ORS.
We recruited over 2,000 providers in India and trained actors to pose as parents seeking treatment for their child’s diarrhea. These actors randomly expressed a preference for ORS, antibiotics, or no preference. Some indicated purchasing medicine elsewhere to control for financial motives. Half the participating towns received a guaranteed ORS supply to test stockout effects.
Surprisingly, provider perception of patient preference for antibiotics was the biggest culprit, contributing to 42% of underprescription. Stockouts and financial incentives played a minor role at 6% and 5%, respectively.
When patients expressed a preference for ORS, prescription rates soared by 27 percentage points. This impact was significantly greater than eliminating stockouts or removing financial incentives.
Clear communication between patients and doctors is key to boosting ORS use and saving lives. When patients actively share their preference for ORS, its use increases significantly.
These results can be used to inform interventions that address provider misperceptions and empower patients to express their preferences.
Read More:
[USC Today] – This Common Medication Could Save Half a Million Children’s Lives Each Year, So Why Is It Underprescribed?
[Science] – What drives poor quality of care for child diarrhea? Experimental evidence from India
The post Neeraj Sood, University of Southern California – Why a Simple Treatment Isn’t Reaching Children Who Need It appeared first on The Academic Minute.
Lindsey Davis, Worcester Polytechnic Institute – Projects Narrow Self-Efficacy Gaps for Women
Sarah Stanlick, Worcester Polytechnic Institute – Failing Forward with Project-Based Learning
Ryan Madan, Worcester Polytechnic Institute – The Unexpected (and Expected) Benefits of Projects in the Humanities
Kimberly LeChasseur, Worcester Polytechnic Institute – Project-Based Learning: More is Better
Kris Wobbe, Worcester Polytechnic Institute – Maximizing Learning through High-Impact Practices
Niusha Jones, Boise State University – Cheers to Defeat: How Sports Losses Decide Our Choice of Drinks
Diego Luis, Tufts University – Catarina de San Juan
Gerard Dumancas, University of Scranton – Inexpensive Method to Detect Honey Authenticity
Sophia Tintori, New York University – What Chornobyl’s Worms Teach Us About DNA Damage
Ernesto Sagas, Colorado State University – The Haitian Crisis and Foreign Intervention
Morgan Polikoff, University of Southern California – Why Aren’t Parents as Worried as Experts about COVID’s Effects on Kids?
Daniel Lewis, California Institute of Technology – Redwoods: Adaptive Giants
Jacob Sawyer, Alma College – Examining Myths About Grief and Bereavement
Scott Malia, College of the Holy Cross – What Makes Bad Movies So Good?
Matthew Cronin, George Mason University – Why Current Approaches to Workplace Mental Health Aren’t Working
Shinwon Noh, University of St. Thomas – Pathways of Peer Influence on Major Choice
Mahak Nagpal, University of St. Thomas – Technosolutionism
Christopher Wong Michaelson, University of St. Thomas – Work Worth Loving
Danielle Ailts Campeau, University of St. Thomas – Entrepreneurship Across American: Supporting Rural Startup Ecosystems
Seth Ketron, University of St. Thomas – The Marketing Power of VR
Create your
podcast in
minutes
It is Free
Listen With The Lights On
The Roundtable
The Media Project
A New York Minute In History
The Best Of Our Knowledge