Natalie Bollinger and her twin sister Alycia had a difficult childhood. During a particularly rough part of their early teenage years, Natalie struck up a friendship with a much older homeless man named Shawn Schwartz. When they had a falling out & Natalie cut off all ties, Shawn didn't take it well. She posted a very public Facebook status about him and 2 weeks later she went missing. The truth behind what happened is shocking, as is what happened to her sister only 3 years later.
Produced by Jacob Hollabaugh
Join our Patreon for bonus episodes, check out our website for merch, and follow us on TikTok, Instagram & YouTube
Glenn and Betty Sandler | 103
The Hargan's | 102
The Kurim Case | 101
Baffling Stories | 100
Diane Newton King | 99
Missy Avila | 98
Kit Martin | 97
John Darwin | 96
Ray Wright | 95
Ashley Reeves | 94
Latrese Curtis | 93
Thabo Bester | 92
Stacie and Kristie Reed | 91
Bob and Kay Swartz | 90
Angie Dodge | 89
Nikki Whitehead | 88
Yara Gambirasio | 87
Tanya Kach | 86
Susie Newsom Lynch & Fritz Klenner | 85
Jennifer Asbenson | 84
Create your
podcast in
minutes
It is Free
Ghosts of Dallas
Picture The Scene - A True Crime Podcast
Mortal Musings Podcast
True Crime Investigators UK
Dateline NBC
Crime Junkie