The controversy in Israel over the exemption of ultra-Orthodox yeshiva students from military service "has reached a boiling point," former Haaretz journalist and author Yair Ettinger tells host Allison Kaplan Sommer on the Haaretz Podcast.
Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has continually delayed confronting the issue in his years in power, Ettinger notes. But this week, the High Court's deadline for either enshrining exemptions in legislation or enlisting yeshiva students expired. And it did so during a war in which Israelis serving in the army have made tremendous sacrifices, and amid severe discontent with Netanyahu's coalition, which depends on ultra-Orthodox support.
And so, Ettinger says, Israelis who disliked but tolerated the ability of the ultra-Orthodox to avoid army service in the past have now "run out of patience."
"There is a big dissonance in Israel right now regarding the Haredim. Why? Because they are at the peak of their political power, and yet they don't share the duties [of defending the country]." On one hand, "they are the government. They have been the senior partners of Netanyahu for many, many years. And now, when we have an existential moment, and we are fighting a really difficult war, they don't pay any price."
Ettinger, author of the book, "Frayed, the Disputes Unraveling Religious Zionists," also looks at how the judicial overhaul battle is inextricably intertwined with the military exemption controversy, and discusses the growing rift in Orthodox society over religion and society, the role of women and tolerance of LGBTQ individuals.
That rift, he says, is exemplified at the Pride Parade each year, where "you can see many religious Zionists marching and many others [among] them protesting against the parade."
He also notes that while the Gaza war has underlined the cracks between secular Israelis and their Diaspora counterparts, "the opposite is true" among the Orthodox. "Today, they are closer than ever," Ettinger says.
See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
'Israeli-Palestinian Memorial Day ceremony exemplifies what the day after the Gaza war could look like'
'Biden is willing to sacrifice reelection for Israel. That's shocking, heartbreaking and dangerous'
'The campus wars over Gaza suck. But they are not a violent, antisemitic nightmare'
'Young U.S. Jews believe Judaism is about social justice. They ask, does Israel stand for that?'
'If One of Those Missiles Hit Tel Aviv We Would Be in a Very Different, Devastating Situation'
'U.S. military aid to Israel is endangered. More people will say it should be cut'
'The more oppression there is, the more younger Arabs in Israel prefer to identify as Palestinians'
Thomas Friedman, Aluf Benn, Noam Tibon and Amir Tibon on the failures of Oct. 7
Tony Kushner: Israel's Gaza war 'looks a lot like ethnic cleansing to me'
Franklin Foer: 'Simplistic moralism is dividing the world into good and evil, and placing Jews on the side of evil'
'Netanyahu wants the world to accuse Israel of genocide, apartheid and ethnic cleansing'
Former PM Olmert: 'Netanyahu’s overconfidence and arrogance led to October 7'
'Israelis are rejecting Netanyahu. That doesn't mean they are embracing left-wing views'
'This is not our first war, but it's the first war we've seen Israel's credit rating drop'
Israel's former head of military intelligence: 'If we don't offer an alternative, we'll end up with Hamas again'
Rallying for democracy, calling to free hostages: Where Israel's protest movements stand
The ugly price Israel will pay for the decision-making failures that led to October 7
'Can Netanyahu be ousted?' and other burning questions from Haaretz readers
'How can we expect others to empathize with us when we fail to empathize with Palestinians?'
Create your
podcast in
minutes
It is Free
Jim & Bill (It‘s Another Day)
HauntingLive
Dr. Paul’s Worldviews
The Ben Shapiro Show
Morning Wire