In Part 2 of our three-part series, we move beyond the headlines and into the investigation itself; and just as importantly, into the space where verified facts collide with public assumption and social-media speculation.After Part 1 laid out what Jonathan Gerlach was charged with and how the story first broke, this episode slows things down. We examine what investigators actually knew, when they knew it, and how information spread faster than confirmation.This is the episode about process, not panic.What...
In Part 2 of our three-part series, we move beyond the headlines and into the investigation itself; and just as importantly, into the space where verified facts collide with public assumption and social-media speculation.
After Part 1 laid out what Jonathan Gerlach was charged with and how the story first broke, this episode slows things down. We examine what investigators actually knew, when they knew it, and how information spread faster than confirmation.
This is the episode about process, not panic.
What we cover in
Part 2:- How the investigation unfolded behind the scenes
- What law enforcement could confirm early on and what remained unclear
- The difference between documented evidence and public inference
- How social media posts, screenshots, and secondhand claims shaped the narrative
- Why some details went viral despite lacking verification
- The ethical risks of online sleuthing when a case involves human remains
- How speculation can unintentionally obscure victims, timelines, and accountability
⚠️ Content AdvisoryThis episode includes discussion of:- Human remains
- Cemetery theft
- Ongoing investigations
- Online speculation and misinformation
Details are discussed factually and non-graphically, with an emphasis on ethical reporting and restraint.
Come back for part 3!Part 3: A comparison between Gerlach and Ed Gein; why the comparison exists, where it breaks down, and why it matters. The historical and investigative significance of Mount Moriah Cemetery, how investigators narrowed their focus, and what the next steps are in this case in terms of identifying and contacting loved ones who were affected by this heinous crime.
Until next time, stay inside, stay alive.References13WHAM. (2026). Ephrata man Jonathan Gerlach admits to selling human remains stolen from Pennsylvania cemetery. https://13wham.com/news/nation-world/ephrata-man-jonathan-gerlach-admits-to-selling-human-remains-stolen-from-pa-cemetery-search-warrant-delaware-county-philadelphia-mount-moriah-cemetery-lancaster-pennsylvania-skulls-skeletons-pa
Courthouse News Service. (2026). Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Jonathan Gerlach: Corpse theft and desecration cemetery docket [Court document]. https://www.courthousenews.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/pennsylvania-v-jonathan-gerlach-corpse-theft-desecration-cemetery-docket.pdf
LancasterOnline. (2026a). A look at investigation of human remains thefts linked to Ephrata suspect: Full coverage. https://lancasteronline.com/news/local/a-look-at-investigation-of-human-remains-thefts-linked-to-ephrata-suspect-full-coverage/collection_12941079-68a2-4c90-a05f-e00d075c3ae5.html
LancasterOnline. (2026b). PA Attorney General’s Office investigating if Ephrata man stole bodies from Luzerne County. https://lancasteronline.com/news/local/pa-attorney-generals-office-investigating-if-ephrata-man-stole-bodies-from-luzerne-county/article_3601b4ff-7eaf-44c0-b01f-c4204b5ac266.html
LancasterOnline. (2026c). Ephrata man charged in cemetery thefts linked to man going to prison in human remains case. https://lancasteronline.com/news/local/ephrata-man-charged-in-cemetery-thefts-linked-to-man-going-to-prison-in-human-remains/article_0faa53fc-d832-4dc8-ae61-a98c62d9e5ce.html
New York Post. (2026, January 10). Police find “horror movie” of stolen bones in alleged grave robber’s home. https://nypost.com/2026/01/10/us-news/police-find-horror-movie-of-stolen-bones-in-alleged-graverobbers-home/
YouTube. (2026). News coverage of Jonathan Gerlach investigation [Video]. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vspfw6cO4ok
View more
