Geek culture icon Felicia Day joins Nancy Cartwright for a hilarious, heartfelt, and candid conversation about The Guild, Buffy the Vampire Slayer, Supernatural, voice acting, anxiety, independent filmmaking, and what happens when creators stop waiting for Hollywood's permission.Felicia looks back at how The Guild helped prove that creators could make their own shows, build their own communities, and succeed outside the traditional entertainment system. Nearly two decades later, she...
Geek culture icon Felicia Day joins Nancy Cartwright for a hilarious, heartfelt, and candid conversation about The Guild, Buffy the Vampire Slayer, Supernatural, voice acting, anxiety, independent filmmaking, and what happens when creators stop waiting for Hollywood's permission.
Felicia looks back at how The Guild helped prove that creators could make their own shows, build their own communities, and succeed outside the traditional entertainment system. Nearly two decades later, she reflects on seeing a new generation of filmmakers follow that path and why she believes creators have more opportunities than ever to connect directly with audiences.
She also opens up about the Kickstarter behind her return to The Guild, the realities of financing an independent movie, and why she's putting the project directly in the hands of fans rather than changing her creative vision to satisfy executives or industry expectations.
Felicia shares the incredible story of how a nerve-racking audition for Buffy the Vampire Slayer unexpectedly became one of the most important breaks of her career. After struggling with her original audition, a spontaneous cold read landed her the role of a Potential Slayer and helped her realize that her wonderfully nerdy, unconventional self had a home in Hollywood.
The conversation gets personal as Felicia discusses the anxiety that followed her through the early years of her career and the pressure she put on herself as both an actor and creator. She reveals what she wishes she could tell the younger version of herself making The Guild on a tiny budget and why learning to stop anticipating disaster changed her perspective on creativity and success.
She also tells a brutal-but-transformative Hollywood story about showing up to work on a major network comedy pilot only to discover that her character had been written out—and nobody had told her. That painful experience ultimately helped push Felicia toward investing in The Guild, her own creative work, and the community already waiting for what she wanted to make.
Meanwhile, Felicia turns the tables and interviews Nancy about the origins of Bart Simpson, including Nancy's original audition for Lisa, recognizing herself in Bart instead, and landing the role on the spot. They also revisit the earliest Tracey Ullman Show recording sessions and how those tiny animated shorts eventually became a television phenomenon.
And, of course, things get wonderfully ridiculous. Felicia shares the hilariously humbling experience of seeing her "Do You Want to Date My Avatar" costume displayed at the Smithsonian, only to stand beside it unnoticed while museum visitors focused on Xena. Nancy and Felicia also talk My Little Pony, memorable fan encounters, rate donuts, and perform an unexpected crossover featuring Nelson Muntz applying to join The Guild.
Felicia also discusses her graphic novel The Lost Daughter of Sparta, what's next for The Guild, and why creating art can have an impact far beyond anything its creator could ever predict.
Whether you're a longtime fan of The Guild, Buffy, Supernatural, My Little Pony, The Simpsons, or simply someone chasing a creative dream, this episode is packed with laughs, behind-the-scenes stories, hard-earned wisdom, and a powerful reminder that sometimes the best response to a closed door is to build your own.
