Matthew is joined by historian Neil J. Young, co-host of the excellent Past Present Podcast, to talk about his new book: Coming Out Republican: a History of the Gay Right.
Young’s riveting storytelling shows how, beginning in the aftermath of WWII, many American gay men—born into socially conservative and religious families from which they had struggled to individuate—hitched the wagon of their political hopes to a Republican party they believed would champion their privacy and individual civil rights.
Ground zero for their fiercely libertarian clubs and action committees was San Francisco, where a culture of rugged entrepreneurship fostered the slogan “Keep the government out of our bedrooms, and out of our wallets.” It was an individualist politics that looked to Civil Rights and women’s rights movements for inspiration, but not allyship.
In time that same GOP would lead a culture war against everything queer—paradoxically led by closeted gay politicians who, with deeply conflicted motives, legislated against their fellows. But even as the tide turned, many gay Republicans kept their shoulders to the unforgiving wheel of respectability politics.
Young illuminates the flashes of bravery and self-reliance in these men’s stories, but also shows what happens when a marginalized group seeks acceptance and political power—instead of liberation—within a culture built on exclusion.
Neil writes for WaPo, the Atlantic, CNN, the Los Angeles Times, Vox, Politico, Slate, and the New York Times.
Show NotesComing Out Republican: A History of the Gay Right, Young
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Brief: Religion is Not Belief? (w/Blair Hodges)
204: What the Hell is RFK Jr Doing?
Bonus Sample: Let's Talk About Gary Brecka
Deep Cut: On Belief
203: Is This a Joke? (w/Neal Brennan)
Bonus Sample: The Dark Sun, The Red Cow, and The End of Days
Brief: Yoga Teacher’s Survival Guide (w/Theo Wildcroft & Harriet McAtee)
202: Steve Hassan and the Trans Cult Conspiracy Theory
Bonus Sample: Long Haul Stories: Matthew Stillman
201: Librarians Are Not Groomers (w/Heath Umbreit)
Bonus Sample: Project 2025's Disdain for Public Education
Brief: The High Cost of Wellness
200: Rogan-Rufo Reality Check
Bonus Sample: The GOP Thinks Food Stamps Are the Real Problem
Brief: Woman, Life, Freedom (w/Negin Shiraghaei)
Brief: Yes, Huberman’s Behavior Matters
199: Inside Anti-Abortion Christian Nationalism (w/Rob Schenck)
Bonus Sample: Conspirituality and the Imaginary Children (Series Intro)
Brief: Unmasking Jay Shetty (w/John McDermott)
Create your
podcast in
minutes
It is Free
The Hello Heaven Podcast
If Books Could Kill
The Bulwark Podcast
48 Hours
Devoted To Prayer
Cast The Word