This episode is rated a 5 (on my Serious Crime Scale). When police found 24-year-old University of Florida student Michelle Herndon dead in her home, it appeared that, in an ironic twist of fate, the health-conscious young woman had suddenly and tragically passed away from natural causes. Although rare, situations like these aren’t as completely out of the ordinary as one might think. So, investigators began processing the case as such – a bizarre death due to natural circumstances. But the case took a sharp turn when the medical examiner discovered a tiny, meticulous needle prick in Michelle’s left arm, which soon led investigators to believe that Michelle had actually been murdered. Ultimately, it would take nearly three years and an international manhunt before her killer would be brought to justice. Listen now to hear the full story.
Chronicle 78: "A Quadruple Homicide"
Chronicle 77: "A Friend's Betrayal"
Chronicle 76: "A Pristine Print"
Chronicle 75: "When She Tried to Leave"
Chronicle 74: "A Negligent Homicide"
Chronicle 73: "A Chance Encounter"
Chronicle 72: "Suspension Sparks Murder"
Chronicle 71: "Robbery Leads to Homicide"
Chronicle 70: "Finding Their Friend"
Chronicle 69: "A Deadly Dispute"
Chronicle 67: "Two Victims, One Killer"
Chronicle 66: "The Disappearance of Charlie Allen Jr. (AKA: Neo)"
Chronicle 65 (Part 2): "Tenure Denied - A Professor's Revenge"
Chronicle 65 (Part 1): "Tenure Denied - A Professor's Revenge"
Chronicle 64: "Should've Known - The Murder of Alex Kogut"
Chronicle 63: "Rivalry, Revenge, & Homicide"
*SPECIAL ANNOUNCEMENT!*
Chronicle 62: "Murder at an Ivy League"
Chronicle 61: "The Haunting of Room 428"
Create your
podcast in
minutes
It is Free
Ghosts of Dallas
Mortal Musings Podcast
True Crime Investigators UK
Scaredycast
Dateline NBC
Crime Junkie