Erin Patterson Appeal: Mushroom Murder Trial Conviction and Sentence Challenged

The Erin Patterson matter is before the Victorian Court of Appeal this week, in the form of two major challenges to the outcome of Australia’s infamous mushroom murder trial.

In this episode of The Mushroom Murder Trial Podcast, we examine the Department of Prosecutions (DPP) appeal against Erin Patterson’s sentence and Patterson’s own appeal against her convictions for murdering Don and Gail Patterson and Heather Wilkinson, and attempting to murder Ian Wilkinson, after a deadly July 2023 family lunch involving death cap mushrooms.

Patterson was sentenced to life imprisonment with a 33-year non-parole period. The DPP argues the sentence was too lenient, while Patterson maintains her innocence and has appealed her convictions on seven grounds, including claims concerning the prosecution’s closing address, cross-examination, cell tower evidence, death cap mushroom evidence and the jury’s sequestration arrangements.

The Court of Appeal will hear the matters in Melbourne on Wednesday and Thursday.

We also provide an update on the podcaster’s separate investigation into Virginia Giuffre, Jeffrey Epstein’s most prominent Australian survivor, and asks whether Australia failed to protect her before her death in April 2025.

Find out how you can support that project for free - plus help with ideas including future petitions and letters to parliamentarians and other calls for transparency — at the end of the episode. Find out here for free why the project is important.

Topics: Erin Patterson, mushroom murder trial, death cap mushrooms, Erin Patterson appeal, Victorian Court of Appeal, DPP appeal, appeal against conviction, Don Patterson, Gail Patterson, Heather Wilkinson, Ian Wilkinson, Virginia Giuffre, Jeffrey Epstein, Australia.

The Mushroom Murder Trial Podcast is hosted by investigative journalist Lisa Tait.

Support the show

Mushroom Murder Trial YouTube
Twitter @lisapodcasts

My free Substack

YouTube Virginia Giuffre