Is Tropical Astrology Sustainable?

In this thought-provoking solo episode, I share my journey of discovering the difference between tropical and true sidereal astrology, and why this matters for Human Design, Gene Keys, and our understanding of celestial influences.

The Core Question:

If tropical astrology is based on where celestial bodies were 2,000+ years ago rather than where they actually are in the sky today, is this system sustainable long-term?

What I Explore:

The precession of the equinoxes - roughly every 72 years, the position of celestial bodies shifts about 1 degree, creating almost a 30-degree difference over 2,000 years

Why when you read "full moon in Aquarius," it's most likely actually in Capricorn when you look at the real sky

My personal shift from tropical to true sidereal astrology and how it affected my human design work

The emotional responses people have when discovering their "sun sign" might be different than they've always believed

The Bigger Picture:

I draw parallels between this astronomical reality and other areas where we've blindly followed systems that drift away from nature (like the margarine vs. butter example in nutrition). Sometimes what seems "easier" or more standardized isn't necessarily more aligned with natural reality.

True sidereal astrology uses actual constellation sizes - some are huge (Virgo, Pisces) while others are small (Aries, Scorpio) - reflecting the irregularities of nature rather than the artificial 30-degree divisions of tropical astrology.

My Perspective:

This isn't about right vs. wrong - it's about personal resonance and what feels authentic to you. I respect that different systems work for different people, and I'm simply sharing what I've discovered resonates deeply with me after years of exploration.

I wonder if our society's rush and disconnection from natural timing partly stems from following astrological systems that are always "ahead" of what's actually happening in the sky.

The Invitation:

Check the sky yourself using free apps. Look up where planets actually are versus where tropical astrology says they are. Make your own informed choice about what resonates with your experience.

If this triggers resistance in you, that's completely normal - it may simply not be the right time for you to explore this. Trust your own timing and inner knowing.

Resources:

Mastering the Zodiac (Athen Chimenti's work): https://masteringthezodiac.com/midpoint-method

NYT article: https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2025/upshot/zodiac-signs.html

Sky-viewing apps to check actual planetary positions

This episode is perfect for anyone interested in astrology, human design, or questioning systems we've accepted without examination.

Connect with Analena:

https://www.instagram.com/analena.fuchs/

https://analenafuchs.com/

#astrology #humandesign #sidereal #genekeys