Oversharing Flaws and Failure Porn

Should you highlight your flaws to stand out, or does "failure porn" turn listeners off? David breaks down the difference and reveals what really makes your podcast matter in this episode of Build a Big Podcast ...

Big Ideas in This Episode

• Why “perfect” podcasts bore people ... and how to stop
• Oversharing your flaws? It’s failure porn
• Listeners crave authenticity, not your confessions
• Your podcast: church, cult, or community?
• Podcast hosts: main character or just a guide?
• Master relatability without wallowing in misery
• Is it about you or your listeners’ desires?

Why You Should Listen

• Why “oversharing” could be killing your podcast’s credibility ... and what to do instead
• The one flaw top creators secretly use to make listeners hang on every word
• How to seduce your audience’s attention by being “rough around the edges” ... and why perfection could be costing you downloads
• When sharing your biggest weaknesses can backfire ... and turn your show into a punchline
• The dirty secret behind “failure porn”—are you accidentally making your podcast all about YOU?
• How to channel the envy of your audience into podcast growth (without being shameless)
• The subtle art of imperfection: use it to sound more authentic—and get listeners to trust you
• The difference between being relatable and wallowing in self-pity (most hosts get this dead wrong)
• The juggler’s trick for making your podcast more addictive (miss this and your episodes sound robotic)
• Why listeners crave “real” podcasts—but will tune out if you keep dropping the ball
• Unlock the gluttony for drama: how to sprinkle “dirt” into your show to keep them coming back
• Gain power over your competition by knowing exactly which flaws to reveal—and which to bury
• Are you suffering from Main Character Syndrome? Discover the truth about who your podcast should really be about
• The path to podcast riches: why focusing on the present (not your past pains) convinces listeners (and sponsors) to pay up
• The lazy podcaster’s guide to building a show that people miss when you’re gone (and beg for more)

Episode Timestamps

• [00:01:40] Should you really showcase your flaws as a podcaster ... or is that terrible advice?
• [00:02:24] The danger of "failure porn": Why oversharing might be killing your credibility
• [00:03:18] What evangelical church testimonies teach us about content creation (and the real reason people fixate on flaws)
• [00:03:59] “We’ve all got a church” ... How the ‘Church of Big Podcast’ uses relatable flaws to build trust and loyalty
• [00:04:36] Are you making your podcast about you or your audience? The “main character syndrome” mistake even pro podcasters make
• [00:05:51] What juggling can teach you about podcast authenticity—and when dropping the ball just turns listeners off
• [00:06:17] The secret line between being “real” and being boring: Why perfect podcasts are forgettable but flawed ones are sticky

You want these links ...

• Subscribe to Build a Big Podcast
• See Big Podcast AMP for personalized podcast growth assistance

The Newsletter for Podcasters

• Big Podcast Insider - Weekly Podcasting Newsletter ​

Big Podcast Insider is a weekly newsletter on podcasting. If you like the content of this episode, you can subscribe here – it's free and you can unsubscribe at any time with a single click.​

Want more help growing your podcast audience?

• Big Podcast Extra - Podcasting Tips
• Big Podcast AMP (Audio Monetization Program)