In this interview, Dan Gorman talks with Leigh Eric Schmidt about his 2021 book The Church of Saint Thomas Paine: A Religious History of American Secularism. Despite its title, Schmidt’s book is not a religious biography of Thomas Paine, but rather a survey of the ways that atheists and agnostics have used Paine as a symbol or figure of devotion.
Schmidt organizes his book into sections on secular relics (focusing on Paine’s exhumed, missing body), secular rituals (focusing on nineteenth-century Americans who sought new frameworks for life events), and secular institutions (focusing on attempts to organize various churches of humanity). An epilogue looks at secularism in the twentieth century. Several atheist and free thought congregations earned tax-exempt status as religious organizations, but religious conservatives from the Cold War onward stoked popular fears that secularists wanted to take over America. Throughout the book, Schmidt highlights a fundamental argument in the atheist/nontheist community: Does an absence of belief in God mean an absence of religion and all the things that go with it? As Schmidt’s history of Thomas Paine fans reveals, the answer is no; a religion can operate on functional lines without a belief in God.
Other topics of conversation include the effects of COVID-19 on Schmidt’s research and writing process, the design and semiotics of the book’s hardcover edition, conservative critiques of Schmidt’s support for liberal religion and secularism in public life, and the book’s connection to Schmidt’s earlier Restless Souls (2nd ed. 2012).
Reflections on REF 2021
Presentism and Politics | Discourse! August 2022 (with video)
Unruly Women: Neocolonialism, Race, and Discrimination
Authorities and the Past | Discourse! June 2022 (with video)
Abortion, Climate Change Protests, & Ukraine Invasion | Discourse! May 2022 (with video)
Cults and NRMs: An RSP Remix, Part I
Curanderismo Roundtable
Semana Santa, Diversifying the Seder, Prayer in High School Football, and… Derry Girls? | Discourse! April 2022
Sunday in the Park with Theory
Obeah and Experiments with Power
How “Woke” Is Your Textbook?: Introducing Religious Studies in the 2020s
Ukraine Invasion, Philippine Elections, and Misinformation | Discourse! March 2022 (with video)
Religious Legal Activism: Abortion Rhetoric Among British Evangelicals
The Wilderness of Mirrors: Nationalism, Religion, and Secret Intelligence
The Devil is in the Details! | Discourse! February 2022 (with video)
The Insider/Outsider Problem: An RSP Remix
Spiritual Abuse Roundtable
The Critical Humanist Study of Islam
When Religion Doesn’t Behave | Discourse! January 2022 (with video)
Questioning the Silver Bullet: Critical Approaches for the Study of Ayahuasca
Create your
podcast in
minutes
It is Free
The Hello Heaven Podcast
Devoted To Prayer
Cast The Word
Let Me Be Frank | Bishop Frank Caggiano’s Podcast | Diocese of Bridgeport, CT
The Exorcist Files
The Ancient Tradition