On this day in labor history, the year was 1908.
That was the day the United States Supreme Court decided the case, Muller v. Oregon.
It was a landmark decision in the realm of protective labor legislation.
It restricted the workday to 10 hours for women.
Laundry owner, Curt Muller, required his female employees to work more than 10 hours a day, against Oregon labor laws.
The Supreme Court upheld his conviction and fine.
Protective labor legislation was a product of the reform social movements of the Progressive Era.
Reformers like Jane Addams worked to protect women from industrial dangers that bred physical and moral harm to women.
The decision drove a class-based wedge within the women’s movement that lasted for much of the 20th century.
Working class women generally supported protective labor legislation like Muller.
But Equal Rights Advocates like Alice Paul opposed it.
They argued that protective legislation like Muller rested on stereotypes regarding differences between men and women.
These differences often fueled anti-woman discrimination, state control and financial dependency.
As well, critics remarked the ruling set a precedent for women’s biology as child-bearers, as a basis for separate legislation.
Only later would working class critics note that the ruling did not cover domestics, agricultural workers, or white-collar workers.
The 1938 Fair Labor Standards Act would supplant some parts of Muller with its guarantees for workers of both sexes.
Many working class women later welcomed the passage of Title VII of the Civil Rights Act in 1965, which prohibited employment discrimination.
Some would concede the many flaws of protective labor legislation that held women back.
But women’s rights advocates would continue to debate protective legislation and the Equal Rights Amendment well into the 1970s.
December 7 - Strong Arming Goldminers
December 6 - Breaking Through the Racial Divide
December 5 - Striking in Solidarity
December 4 - Organizing to End Slavery
December 3 - Learning & Labor at Oberlin
December 2 - 21st Century Corporate Greed
December 1 - Standing Up for Themselves and Their Patients
November 30 - Angel of the Stockyards is Born
November 29 - The Fight for $15 & A Union
November 28 - Disaster in the Mines
November 27 - Death Trap in Newark
November 26 - The Birth of William Sylvis
November 25 - Chicago Printers Walk Off the Job
November 24 - The Hollywood Ten
November 23 - The Thibodaux Massacre
November 22 - Uprising of the 20,000
November 21 - Autoworkers Join the Postwar Strike Wave
November 20 - Birth of the Time Clock
November 19 - Joe Hill’s Final Words
November 18 - Accident or Murder?
Create your
podcast in
minutes
It is Free
Regenerative Skills
The Meaningful Life with Andrew G. Marshall
The No-Frills Teacher Podcast
The Jordan B. Peterson Podcast
The Mel Robbins Podcast