Penn’s Cave in Centre Hall, PA: Ghostly Echos from the Deep

In this episode, we dive into the heartbreaking legend of Malachi Boyer, a French trapper who died in the cave after being separated from his forbidden love, Nita-nee, a Seneca maiden. Said to still cry out her name in a French accent, Boyer’s spirit is one of many rumored to haunt the cave's watery passageways. You’ll also hear about disembodied voices, mysterious mists and shadow figures darting between ancient rocks. With reports from investigators, guides, and guests alike, Penn’s Cave may not just be a natural wonder—it could also be one of Pennsylvania’s most underrated haunted hotspots. Settle in and listen closely, you might just hear a whisper from the water.