Ep 6 | When Experts Disagree: Navigating Conflicting Advice

What happens when two equally credentialed experts offer completely opposite medical advice? In this episode of Well Considered, we explore what to do when the science isn’t settled—and the experts don’t agree.

We'll talk about real-world examples, including the ongoing debate between pediatricians Dr. Paul Offit and Dr. Robert Sears on the childhood vaccine schedule, and the emotional toll this kind of conflict can take on parents trying to make the best decisions for their families.

We’ll walk through how to critically evaluate expert advice, spot red flags in messaging, and avoid the trap of reactionary thinking. Plus, we highlight historical and modern-day examples of whistleblowers, dissenting scientists, and innovations that only happened because someone dared to say, “What if we’re wrong?”

Whether you’re navigating vaccine decisions, medical guidance, or just trying to make sense of conflicting health information, this episode will help you build confidence, ask better questions, and stay grounded in your values.

Looking for links? Take the Free Training Course or explore your options on the Partners page.

Follow on Instagram & X: @JustTheInserts

Subscribe & Leave a Review (It helps more parents find this information!) If this episode resonated with you, share it with a friend and let’s empower more families to make informed choices!

Episode Citations:

Dr. Bob Sears' Book

Dr. Robert Malone mRNA Patent, suspension, and interview with Joe Rogan.

 

Vioxx Seeding Trial

Vioxx Controversy

Dr. Semmelweis and Hand Washing

Toxic Chemicals and 3M

 

Leaded Gasoline