Flattened Pastors, Nihilistic Piety, and the Loss of Sacred Office

Ross Byrd returns to the Yours Truly Podcast for a heavy but necessary conversation. We wrestle with what it really means when pastors fall — not just “a sinner like the rest of us,” but men entrusted with sacred office, whose failures ripple through families, churches, and communities.

We dig into Ross’s Patient Kingdom essay on the cliché “There but for the grace of God go I” — asking whether that phrase short-circuits deeper honesty about betrayal, shame, and the costly road back to trust. Along the way we examine Carl Lentz’s story, the revolving door of evangelical scandals, and the flattening of pastoral authority into what Ross calls “nihilistic piety.”

This episode is not about gossip or cynicism. It’s about telling the truth: grace is not a hall pass, forgiveness is not the same as restored trust, and sacred office is more than private accountability.

Mentioned

• Ross Byrd – https://substack.com/@rossbyrd?r=433pnb&utm_medium=ios&utm_source=profile

• Carl Lentz & Lights On podcast: @lightsonwithcarllentz

• Evangelical scandals: Ravi Zacharias, Bill Hybels, Steve Lawson, Robert Morris

• Scripture: 1 Timothy, Acts, Genesis

Key Ideas

• Sacred office isn’t interchangeable with personal piety.

• “Grace” without truth or trust becomes hollow.

• Confession belongs in the light, not just in private.

• Restoration is costly — it takes time, patience, and truth-telling.

👉 If this conversation resonates, please subscribe, share, or consider becoming a channel member to support longform work like this: Join this channel

https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCU5SNBfTo4umhjYz6M0Jsmg/join