I Slept with My Sister’s Husband - Do I Spill or Stay Silent?

This week, we're diving headfirst into the messiest kind of drama: family. What happens when your sister’s relationship is technically open… but you end up hooking up with her husband? Is it betrayal, bad judgment, or just really confusing boundaries? Mel and Suzie break down this jaw-dropping confession, talk through the ethics of open relationships, and ask the big question: when is honesty the right move and when is it just selfish guilt in disguise? Buckle up, this one’s messy.

In this episode, we unpack a wild confession that has us both cringing and clutching our wine glasses: a sister slept with her sister’s husband... and now she doesn’t know whether to confess or keep it zipped. We talk sibling loyalty, messy boundaries, and why "open" doesn’t always mean “anything goes.” It's uncomfortable, a little scandalous, and 100% the kind of tea we live for.

vibr8tor.com: Use Promo MS15

guybrator.com: UsePromo GUY15

Got a story to share with us?

Leave us a voicemail by clicking here.

Email us: stories@sharingmytruth.com or DM us on Instagram

Follow us on Instagram @sharingmytruthpod, TikTok @sharingmytruthpod

Facebook @sharingmytruthpod , YouTube @sharingmytruthpod

Follow Mel @melanyklondon and Suzie @suzsheckter

Sign up to our weekly newsletter and join the Sharing My Truth Community sharingmytruth.com

Visit our website sharingmytruth.com and share your truths with us, check out our latest merch, promo codes from our partners, and much more

Tune in, share your truth, and let’s talk about it