#3: Benny & Joon (1993)

Remember BENNY & JOON, that quirky Johnny Depp movie from the 90s? Dave doesn't--it's in his blind spot! Aidan Quinn stars as an auto mechanic who's made it his life's purpose to care for his mentally ill younger sister (Mary Stuart Masterson). Enter an eccentric, Buster Keaton-type (Depp) who can speak her language and read her emotions, but who's appearance upsets the balance. This week Ashley chooses a "comfort food" movie from her past. And Dave has to confront his Johnny Depp problem.