243 | When The Paranormal & True Crime Collide: Shadows Of Evil

Tonight, we’re stepping into a world where the darkest corners of human nature collide with forces we can’t quite explain. This episode is all about true crime cases that twist into the supernatural—murders, trials, and hauntings where the line between evil deeds and otherworldly influence blurs. We’re diving into four chilling tales: the infamous Amityville Horror, Arne Cheyenne Johnson’s “Devil Made Me Do It” trial, the unsolved Villisca Axe Murders, and the Smurl family’s demonic ordeal. These aren’t just campfire stories—they’re real cases that left investigators, families, and entire communities grappling with questions no one can fully answer.  

Picture this: a man guns down his family, and the house he leaves behind becomes a nightmare of voices and apparitions. A brutal stabbing leads to a courtroom defense of demonic possession. An axe-wielding killer vanishes, but the echoes of his victims linger in a cursed home. A family fights an unseen tormentor for 15 years, claiming it’s hell-bent on their destruction. We’ve got the gritty details—court records, witness accounts, and expert takes from cops, paranormal investigators, and skeptics alike. Is this just human horror with a spooky twist, or could something truly sinister be at play? 

We'll see you on the inside..

----
TIME STAMPS:
0:00 - Shadows of Evil: True Crime & The Supernatural
1:14 - Intro
2:33 - https://holler.baby/thefreakydeaky 
4:03 - Dabbling Into True Crime 
4:53 - My Son Looks Like Joe Rogan From The Back 
5:25 - The Amityville Horror House 
7:23 - ScareBNB (Don't Steal My Idea) 
14:51 - Do You Believe The Amityville Horror Account? 
15:53 - What Lingers After Tragedy? 
18:46 -  Arne Cheyenne Johnson: The Devil Made Me Do It Trial
24:46 - Was Arne Johnson Possessed?  
25:24 - Schizophrenia & The Supernatural Is Episode 250 
28:33 - Can You Sense Personality Shifts In People? 
31:36 - The Villisca Axe Murders (Trigger Warning?)
31:53 - Hey YouTube, Fight Me. 
34:23 - Christian Alienates The Female Audience 
36:23 - This Show Is 83% Sarcasm (Study It) 
39:53 - Zak Bagans Is a Plague 
42:13 - Orbs Are Dust 99.9999999% Of the Time, Folks 
43:23 - Who Goes To Off A Family With No Weapon.. 
45:13 - Most Ghost Hunter Shows Are Cringy & Unbelievable 
47:49 - The Smurl Family Haunting 
48:33 - Scott Knows Music, Mmk?
50:13 - Impossible To Get Rid of The Warrens 
53:59 - Smurl Case: Psychological Strain or Supernatural Experience?
54:13 - Why Video Evidence Is Untrustworthy These Days
57:23 - Notorious Haunted Houses Next Week
58:31 - Outro 

_____________________________________________
+PRODUCERS: Eric Long, Daniel Heng, Anthony M, 

+BECOME A PRODUCER: http://bit.ly/3WZ3xTg
+BUY A $9 SHOUT-OUT: https://holler.baby/thefreakydeaky

The Twilight Zone meets Mystery Science Theatre 3000 meets an uncomfortable Thanksgiving dinner conversation with your in-laws. TFD is a weekly paranormal comedy podcast featuring real ghost stories, Cryptid lore discussions, and true paranormal experiences hosted by believer/skeptic in-laws.

Recorded in an undisclosed location somewhere in the beautiful woods of Wasilla, Alaska.

+SUBMIT YOUR (TRUE) STORY:
—Email: thegang@thefreakydeaky.com  
—Voicemail: 801-997-0051 

+WEBSITE & MERCH:
—Website: www.thefreakydeaky.com 
—Merch: www.thefreakydeaky.com/store 

+JOIN THE DISCUSSION:
—TFD Facebook Group: https://tinyurl.com/tfdfb  
—Instagram: https://bit.ly/2HOdleo  
—Facebook: https://bit.ly/3ebSde6