July 29, 2019 Episode- CONTROVERSY ABOUNDS! We discuss Jane Mayer’s blockbuster on Al Franken; Jill Lepore on Melville; and Hilton Als’ controversial piece on Hannah Gadsby.

Dan and Eric discuss the nature of criticism this issue as well as where the New Yorker tends to situate itself in today's cultural climate.  They start out talking about Jane Meyer's detailed investigation into the allegations against Al Franken.  Dan and Eric move on to talk about Jill Lepore's incisive and expansive essay on Herman Melville, his life and legacy.  They end this episode with a discussion of Hilton Als' criticism of Hannah Gadsby's new performance, "Douglas."  So much to talk about this week as Dan and Eric engage about an extraordinary issue of the magazine.