Dr. Talia Isaacs shares her experiences in journal peer review as an author, reviewer, and editor. She discusses both positive and challenging experiences, including finding a home for mixed methods research and dealing with disciplinary silos. Talia also provides insights on responding to reviewer feedback on methods and defending decisions. She highlights the importance of transparency in acknowledging the use of AI tools in the writing and research process. Talia offers advice to early career researchers on navigating the peer review process, including being resilient, seeking guidance, and understanding disciplinary practices.