Chuck’s Commentary - How Lindsey Graham Should Be Remembered + When Moderates Fail…The Radicals Ascend

Chuck Todd devotes much of this episode to a rich, personal reflection on the death of Senator Lindsey Graham at 71 — a figure who can only be understood if you separate the ideologues from the pure politicians, because Graham was unambiguously the latter. Graham always wanted to be in the middle of the Republican Party, treated his Senate seat as something as precious to him as a spouse, and was a genuine political creature who could nonetheless work with everyone, partnering with both Trump and Obama across his career. Chuck shares personal memories — interviewing Graham alongside John McCain, the two of them giving outsized attention to the Steele Dossier; Graham losing his parents in his 20s and raising his 13-year-old sister; even reassuring Chuck’s own wife about her worries over Trump — and argues that Graham, for all his capitulations, actually served as one of the few moderating forces on Trump. He lays out the very real political fallout: Todd Blanche's confirmation as Attorney General is now in serious jeopardy, Graham leaves a massive vacuum in the GOP conference, and his South Carolina seat could actually be competitive for Democrat Annie Andrews if the Republican primary lurches far enough to the right. From there Chuck draws a series of parallels between American and British politics — Labour returning to power on a promise of competence and stability, Nigel Farage (like Trump) trying to convert political fame into personal wealth, and the satirical candidate "Count Binface" holding up a mirror to a political culture that has become pure theater — musing, only half-jokingly, that America could use its own Count Binface. Chuck closes on a sober note about the U.S.-Israel relationship, which he believes is heading for a real retreat: he recalls how close the region came to a two-state peace two decades ago, how the collapse of that moment allowed radicalism to escalate on both sides until each could argue the other doesn't want peace, and points to Rahm Emanuel's recent speech in Israel — warning that Israel must articulate a vision for what comes after the war or risk isolating itself from younger and moderate Americans — as the sound of someone trying to save a political center that vanishes the moment people conclude moderates don't have answers.

Finally, Chuck hops into the ToddCast Time Machine to break down the messy build up and coalitions involved in the Spanish civil war, and what lessons modern America can take from it. He also answers listeners’ questions in the “Ask Chuck” segment and make a proposal for a change to the baseball Hall of Fame.

From the opening whistle to the final kick. Bet on a match and get bonus bets for every goal scored at Fanduel.com

Protect your family with life insurance from Ethos. Get up to $3 million in coverage in as little as 10 minutes at https://ethos.com/chuck. Application times may vary. Rates may vary.

Refresh your wardrobe with Quince. Go to https://Quince.com/chuck for free shipping on your order and 365-day returns.

Link in bio or go to https://getsoul.com & enter code TODDCAST for 30% off your first order.

Timeline:

(Timestamps may vary based on advertisements)

00:00 Chuck Todd’s introduction

04:15 Senator Lindsey Graham dead at 71

04:45 Reactions to Graham are filtered through one’s personal politics

05:30 There are ideologues and there are politicians. Graham was the latter

06:45 Graham always wanted to be in the middle of the Republican party

09:00 Graham’s senate seat was as important to him as a spouse

11:15 Certain people are just political creatures, like Graham and Cruz

12:45 Graham was able to work with everyone on both sides of the aisle

13:30 Graham worked with both Trump and Obama

15:30 Conspiracy theories are swirling about Graham’s death

16:15 There needs to be a thorough autopsy to put conspiracies to rest

17:30 Chuck interviewed Graham & McCain, they mentioned the Steele Dossier

18:15 Graham and McCain gave the most attention to the Dossier

20:30 Graham’s parents died in his 20s, he raised his 13 year old sister

22:30 Chuck had Graham as a dark horse candidate for 2008

23:15 Graham was aware of the rumors and never addressed them directly

24:30 The real world impact on politics from Graham’s passing

25:00 Todd Blanche’s confirmation is now in serious jeopardy

25:30 Graham leaves a massive vacuum in the GOP conference

28:00 Graham kept Trump from fully going down the fascist road

29:15 Unlike Trump, Graham sees Putin as a threat & backed Ukraine

31:15 Impact on the South Carolina elections

32:00 There will be lots of Republicans looking to jump into the primary

33:15 If primary goes super right-wing, Democrat Annie Andrews has a shot

35:15 Graham reassured Chuck’s wife after expressing worries about Trump

37:45 Graham knew if he had gone hard on Trump, he’d lose his senate seat

38:45 There are parallels between U.S. and U.K politics

39:45 Labour came back into power promising competence and stability

40:45 Nigel Farage, like Trump… is trying to turn political fame into wealth

42:30 “Count Binface” has been challenging Farage as a satirical candidate

43:30 The man who made UK politics theatrical, now facing a theatrical challenge

44:00 The U.S. could really use a “Count Binface” to hold up a mirror

45:15 What if we accepted the premise of politics as entertainment?

46:00 Should we host a political reality show on an island

47:15 Governing experience has become a liability in American politics

48:00 Media rewards performance more than competency

50:15 There is going to be a retreat in the American-Israeli partnership

50:45 20 years ago we were very close to peace & two state solution

52:45 When moderation & compromise fail, radicalism takes its place

54:00 There was a serious chance for peace two decades ago

54:30 After both sides walked away, the radicalism escalated

56:15 The extremes can now argue the other side doesn’t want peace

57:00 Rahm Emmanuel travels to Israel to give speech

58:00 Rahm says Israel must provide vision for what comes after war

59:15 Rahm warns Israel risks isolating itself from younger & moderate Americans

1:00:45 Rahm sounds like someone trying to save the political center

1:02:00 Moderation disappears when it feels like moderates don’t have answers

01:12:00 ToddCast Time Machine - July 17th, 1936

01:12:30 Start of the Spanish civil war

01:13:15 Why does Spain’s civil war stand out in history?

01:14:30 The war wasn’t simply a fight between left and right

01:15:00 1930s Spain had every divide imaginable

01:16:00 Political violence became common, political center got smaller

01:16:45 The left wing coalition that won was barely united at all

01:17:45 Military units in Morocco revolted, then coup spread to Spain

01:18:30 Franco eventually united a fascist coalition with military command

01:19:15 The left’s internal divisions became one of Franco’s advantages

01:20:30 Civilians became part of the battlefield and were targeted

01:22:00 George Orwell’s writing came directly from his experiences in Spain

01:23:15 The fascist wing won the war and Franco ruled until 1975

01:24:00 Pluralism only emerged after decades of authoritarian rule

01:25:30 The transition out of authoritarianism came from exhaustion, not agreement

01:27:00 Sharing power with opponents is preferable to violence

01:28:15 Book recommendations for learning more about the Spanish civil war

01:29:15 Ask Chuck

01:29:30 How can we get back to lasting governance and progress?

01:35:00 Could Trump run as VP or speaker then ascend back to the presidency?

01:38:15 Why do prominent political interviews not have aggressive follow ups?

01:44:45 Who was the best pitcher of this generation that’s retiring?

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.