Links:
About This Episode:
There has been much debate about the role of nutritional reductionism in research. This approach generally aims to study diet’s effects by breaking down the intricate web of dietary factors into smaller, more manageable components. But critics have asked does this approach truly capture the full picture of nutrition’s influence on our well-being?
In an attempt to help answer research questions there has been a proposal for the use of “nutritional geometry”, a framework that delves into the multidimensional relationships between nutrients and their effects on organisms. Within this framework, the protein leverage hypothesis emerges, proposing that our bodies prioritize protein intake and adjust food consumption accordingly. But how does this theory fit into the broader spectrum of nutrition science, and what implications does it hold for understanding and managing our diets?
Additionally, as aim to do better nutrition research, we are met with philosophical questions that challenge traditional reductionist views. Is it enough to simply dissect foods into their nutrient components, or do we need a more holistic understanding of dietary patterns and their impact on health?
In this episode, Prof. David Raubenheimer and Dr. Jonathan Sholl discuss the need to have an approach where science meets philosophy, and where reductionism meets synthesis. And we dive into ideas they have proposed that make a defense of some aspects of reductionism.
#520: How Exercise Impacts Appetite, Food Intake and Adiposity – James Dorling, PhD
SNP28: How To Eat for Longevity
#519: Eating Disorders: Inpatient Treatment & Challenges – Helen West, RD
#517: Reflecting on Ten Years of Lessons
#516: How to Read Nutrition Studies (Become Confident in Critically Appraising Research)
AMA: Do Low-carbers Need Less Vitmain C? Does Omega-3 Supplementation Actually Benefit Us? & More (SNP 27)
#515: Does Dietary Fat Quality Causally Affect Atherosclerosis Risk? – Jacob Christensen, PhD
#514: Plant-derived Fatty Acids – Ella Baker, PhD
#513: Kidney Stones & Diet – Deepa Kariyawasam, RD
What are Dietary Reference Intakes? Origins, Development & Use (SNP 26)
#512: Alzheimer’s Disease – Drs. Ayesha & Dean Sherzai
#511: Null By Design – When “No Effect” Doesn’t Mean No Effect
#510: Social Comparison: Evidence on its Impacts & What We Can Do – Shannon Beer
AMA: Coconut Oil, Raw Oats, Collagen, & More! (SNP 25)
#509: Helping Clients & Patients Overcome Nutrition Confusion – Jono Steedman, APD
#508: Why Athletes Can Achieve High Performance During an Energy Deficit – Jose Areta, PhD
#507: Does a Higher Portfolio Diet Score Reduce Heart Disease? – Andrea Glenn, PhD
Listener Q&A: Homocysteine, MUFA, Healhty BMI, and more! (Preview)
#506 Sports Nutrition: Translating Research to Practice – Andreas Kasper, PhD
Create your
podcast in
minutes
It is Free
Practically Healthy by Dr. Melina
ZOE Science & Nutrition
Intermittent Fasting Stories
Biohacking Superhuman Performance
Nutrition Diva