With apologies for the pun, the Fifteenth Court of Appeals faces an “unprecedented” situation.
Unlike the other intermediate courts of appeal in Texas, the newly created Fifteenth Court of Appeals has no immediate predecessor. The Legislature gave it statewide jurisdiction over specific kinds of cases, as opposed to general jurisdiction over cases from a particular geographic area. As a result, that court does not start with an “inherited” body of precedent.
The Fifteenth Court thus faces a novel—and fundamental—question: what is its precedent?
This episode examines five sources of insight for answering that question: (1) English common law (as defined by a Texas statute dating back to the Republic); (2) “vertical” precedent, as described by a 2022 supreme court case; (3) federal practice about the Erie doctrine; (4) generally recognized conflicts-of-laws principles; and (5) historical examples from the 1840s, when the Supreme Court of the Republic of Texas confronted a similar problem with a lack of precedent.
Interview with Dr. Ben Voth about James Farmer, Jr.
How Good is Generative AI? ChatGPT and I Co-Author a Tale
Can the Texas Supreme Court do that? "Adminstrative stays" in the state courts of Texas
University Presidents, Calls for Genocide, and Aristotle
Jury Consultant Jason Bloom Returns - The "New Normal" of Jury Selection for 2024
How to Fix Political-Candidate Debates
Slavery and the Republic of Texas Supreme Court: What Can we Learn?
Mifepristone May: Upcoming Argument About "Conservatism"
Are "Business Courts" Acceptable Under the Texas State Constitution?
Interview with ChatGPT
"WWHD"? How should courts use the question: "What Would Hamilton Do?"
Coale Kids on Book Bans, Dress Codes, and Motto Posters
Abortion Access as a Human Right: Interview With Julie F. Kay
The National Motto, the Texas Legislature, and the Southlake Dragons
God, Sex, Life, and Dobbs: Who are the "People's Elected Representatives"?
Abortion Travel Restrictions After Dobbs: Constitutional?
The Administrative State Strikes Back?
Originalism and its Discontents
Cities and Counties as Post-Roe Bulwarks: Who Are the "People's Elected Representatives"?
Create your
podcast in
minutes
It is Free
City Manager Unfiltered
Potencial Americano
The ASIC Podcast
The Chris Plante Show
Red Eye Radio