James Gheerbrant, Jonathan Northcroft and Gregor Robertson join tom Clarke to give VAR a grilling.
Does the mic’d up programme help or hinder the case for VAR in games? The team look at issues around how subjective football is, how effective current VAR is and are there other, better options to use the technology? After an inconclusive but heated debate it’s on to England’s midfield.
Bellingham and Rice seem certain starters, but who plays alongside them? Do England have a defensive midfielder, and if not, who plays instead?
Finally, Jonny recently voted in a poll asking who are currently the world’s best players…he names his top five.
Timeline
VAR
2’ VAR, are the audio releases helping or hindering
4’ Pain is not worth the gain. It is a really difficult job, but it has become farcical.
8’ Running VAR can be exhausting, in the spotlight, no clear right and wrong, walking a tightrope
Possible clips
11’ the number and detail of incidents can’t be assessed in the time allowed.
15’ modern mania to achieve perfection…in a subjective sport.
17’ timing is an issue; it takes too long the flow of the game has been affected.
20’ Has the mic’d up programme improved things or further mudded the waters.
22’ sin bins. Good idea or not? Keeping refs mics on would stop player dissent quickly.
26’ do players influence VAR by appealing and asking refs to check things.
England midfield
31’ who plays alongside Declan Rice and Jude Bellingham.
33’ the chemistry of the three is important. Southgate prizes control over everything else. Gregor thinks still Philips.
35’ can’t pick Philips or Henderson because of lack of top flight football.
37’ Trent Alexander is the answer according to Jonny.
40’ James, consider Connor Gallagher.
45’ stones, Rico Lewis, Foden Maddison. Jonny think whoever Jude wants Keep Bellingham happy.
Best players in the world
49’ Jonny voted for worlds best players. Hard to over look Premier league and England players. Haland, Rodri, Kane, Bellingham.
55’ Kane now getting the coverage he deserves.
57’ Messi still the man. What about defenders??
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
Advantage Liverpool, will they hold on..?
Who starts for England at the Euros?
How to make England better..?
Is Mainoo the answer to England's midfield issues?
The best game of the season...?
The Dark Arts…
The best title race in years – so who wins?
Is European football becoming boring?
Who is better than Phil Foden?
Fathers, sons, money and mavericks
Klopp's kids triumph and dealing with mardy managers
George Elokobi: "We dance one more time."
"We’re Manchester United and we’re coming to get you." Really…?
The title race, Kane's understudy and Lemon Meringue Pie
Who owns your club? Kane’s trophy hunt, and Man Utd’s big signing
Arsenal for the title? Spurs for fourth? But what is Scott McTominay?
Sin bin's and the celebration police
Gunners fire, Liverpool stall. United hope, Chelsea despair
Defying expectations: Luton, Eze, Tevez and Bradley
Liverpool’s next manager, Maidstone’s current manager and the Rashford mystery
Create your
podcast in
minutes
It is Free
Football Weekly
The Athletic FC Podcast
The Totally Football Show with James Richardson
The News Agents
Freakonomics Radio