When feelings for another person run deep, people are often inclined to see the best in that person. It’s not uncommon for unsettling behavior to be excused rather than seeing it as a warning sign and acting on it. But this idealism can put someone in harm’s way without them realizing it until it’s much too late. When Nicole Montalvo went missing in October 2019, investigators quickly learned that a lot was going on in her personal life and sadly, her circumstances were not all that unusual. Nicole’s disturbing murder led to three arrests and one trial.
Let’s get social: Follow MURDERISH on Instagram & TikTok @MurderishPodcast. We’re also on Facebook.
Visit murderish.com to learn more about Jami and the podcast. You can also buy merch & sign up to become a MURDERISH | Behind the Mic Patreon member and get access to exclusive perks.
Listening to this podcast doesn’t make you a murderer, it just means you’re murder …ish.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Best of MURDERISH- E79 “Whitey Bulger: Robin Hood Mob Boss”
Carl Smalls Jr. | MURDERISH Ep. 143
Best of MURDERISH - S&S Liquor Store Murders “A Family Affair” E68
Theranos: “Scam Box” | Serial Streamers TV Club
Tristan Beaudette: “Murdered in Malibu” | MURDERISH Ep. 142
Best of MURDERISH- E54 Keith Green
NXIVM Cult: “Branded, Trafficked & Tricked” | Serial Streamers TV Club
Bernice & Ben Novack Jr. “Fortune Turned Fatal”丨MURDERISH Ep. 141
Best of MURDERISH - E47 Lauren Key, “What Happened on the Cliff?”
Michelle Carter: "Texting Murder" | Serial Streamers TV Club
Lawrence Family: “Collateral Damage” | MURDERISH Ep. 140
Introducing: Murder, She Told
Best of MURDERISH - E31 The "Smoked" Murders
Mary Kay Letourneau | Serial Streamers TV Club
Chad O’Melia: “Deaf to Justice” | MURDERISH Ep. 139
Best of MURDERISH - E16 The Hendricks Murders
Skylar Neese: “A Best Friend’s Betrayal” | MURDERISH Ep. 138
Best of MURDERISH - E7 Terra Newell - Dirty John
Donnivan Schaeffer: Donut Shop Murder - MURDERISH Ep. 137
Ruth Pelke: “A Redemption Tale” | MURDERISH Ep. 136
Create your
podcast in
minutes
It is Free
Picture The Scene - A True Crime Podcast
Mortal Musings Podcast
True Crime Investigators UK
Dateline NBC
Crime Junkie