While most schools in the United States do not report using corporal punishment – the use of pain as punishment -- it still impacts tens of thousands of students annually, particularly in states where it remains legal.
Jaime Peterson, a pediatrician and assistant professor at Oregon Health and Science University, along with the American Academy of Pediatrics, issued a call this fall to end such practices in school. “As pediatricians, we don't recommend corporal punishment. We know it's not an effective form of discipline. Spanking and hitting a child might help a behavior in the short term. They might be fearful and obedient,” she says. “But in the long term it has a lot of negative consequences. But if it's how you discipline your child at home, parents are often teachers, and school personnel, and school board members that that's a practice in their community at home that seems acceptable. It may be hard to change it.”
It also disproportionately impacts certain demographics such as Black students and students with disabilities.
With 17 states remaining where corporal punishment is still legal today, Peterson urges parents, educators and policymakers to mobilize and push for abolition of this practice. Calling this form of punishment ineffective, she urges parents and schools to adopt more supportive and positive disciplinary practices that work.
“Saying that it's not allowed isn't going to change a school culture entirely. We don't know what other forms of discipline will come in,” she says. “I think really in the simplest forms when I talk with families, I remind them that our goal is no pain-- so that's corporal punishment-- no shame, and no blame when we discipline children. No pain, no shame, no blame.”
In this episode of the EdCast, we discuss the prevalence and effects of corporal punishment in schools, and what it’s going to take to end it for good.
What Test Scores Actually Tell Us
Colleges as Courageous Spaces
Prioritizing Student Mental Health in College
Why We Need to Rethink Recess
Higher Education's Biggest Conundrums
Facing Challenges, Driving Success (in Chicago)
A Classic Problem -- Putting Diverse Books into Practice
Understanding Immigration
The Quest for Deeper Learning in High Schools
EdCast Extra: Teens Get Real About Inequity in College Access
Putting Ethics First in College Admissions
The Making of a Bully-free School
Redefining School Counseling
Broadening Global Perspectives
The Desegregation Compromise
Moving Beyond Technical in Computer Science Education
The Complexities of Teacher Strikes
Overparented, Underprepared
The Rights of Public School Students
Replicating Effective Charter School Practice
Create your
podcast in
minutes
It is Free
The HBR Channel
Women and Public Policy Program Seminar Series
PolicyCast
Shorenstein Center Media and Politics Podcast
Harvard Center for International Development