President Biden just signed into law a bill forcing the sale of TikTok by its Chinese parent ByteDance—or else face an outright ban. The measure was included in a bill providing a $95.3 billion foreign aid package for Israel, Ukraine, and Taiwan.
Proponents of the bill cite privacy and national security concerns. TikTok, like all social media giants, collects piles of user data—and if requested by the Chinese Communist Party, ByteDance is obligated by law to share that user information. Critics also worry about political influence operations on the platform—a dictatorial foreign adversary turning our kids into little Manchurian candidates.
Opponents of the bill argue that forcing a TikTok sale under the threat of a ban is a blow to users’ free speech rights and represents an overreach of government authority. They insist that the government should not dictate which apps Americans can use, especially on opaque grounds of national security.
Today, a debate: Is American national security at risk from an Orwellian app ultimately controlled by a totalitarian regime? Or is this just McCarthyism in digital form, a government-created moral panic fueled by dubious threats of misinformation?
Arguing that the TikTok bill is a logical extension of our current laws—and a necessary countermeasure to authoritarian meddling—is Geoffrey Cain. Cain is the author of The Perfect Police State and senior fellow at the National Security Institute of George Mason University.
On the other side, arguing that the bill is a dangerous overreach justified by flimsy evidence of an alleged threat, is Walter Kirn. Kirn is a novelist, Free Press contributor, editor-at-large of County Highway, and co-host of the podcast America This Week.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Honestly Presents: The Witch Trials of J.K. Rowling
Why Nikki Haley Is Running for President
A Gen Z Religious Revival: 250 Hours of Worship in Kentucky
Will Ozempic Solve Obesity in America? A Debate
Why 65% of Fourth Graders Can't Really Read
A Golden Age of Gurus
America's Role in the Holocaust: Ken Burns on The Most Important Film He Will Ever Make
America’s Broken Immigration System: An Honest Debate
Raw & Unclassified: A Friday Roundtable
Bad Moms with Emily Oster
A Holiday Treat with David Sedaris!
The Twitter Files and the Future of the Democratic Party With Silicon Valley's Congressman
The State of the Black-Jewish Relationship in America: A Roundtable
Bibi Netanyahu: Israel's New Prime Minister. Again.
A Better Way to Disagree
Nuclear War Games with HR McMaster
The Midterms No One Saw Coming: A Postmortem
Who Do Voters Hate More? A Midterm Roundtable.
Has Criminal Justice Reform Made Us Less Safe? A Debate.
Why We Must Save Our Boys
Create your
podcast in
minutes
It is Free
The Modern West
The Commentary Magazine Podcast
Conversations with Tyler
UnHerd with Freddie Sayers
heretics. | andrew gold
Making Sense with Sam Harris