Into the Impossible With Brian Keating
Science:Natural Sciences
Recently, Bergner and Seligman explained the behavior of the first interstellar object, ‘Oumuamua, as a rare form of a quite common object, a comet. They claim it "began as an icy planetesimal that was irradiated at low temperatures by cosmic rays during its interstellar journey, and experienced warming during its passage through the Solar System. This explanation is supported by a large body of experimental work."
But Avi Loeb disagrees: “In a new paper published recently in Nature -- https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-022-05687-w Acceleration of 1I/‘Oumuamua from radiolytically produced H2 in H2O ice -- Jennifer Bergner and Darryl Seligman suggest that the peculiar acceleration observed by the first known interstellar object `Oumuamua, can be explained if `Oumuamua was made of water ice which was partly dissociated into hydrogen by cosmic-rays along its interstellar journey. In the abstract of the paper, the authors admit that past models involving a pure hydrogen iceberg or a pure nitrogen iceberg do not work due to theoretical or observational inconsistencies. In fact, the hydrogen iceberg model was proposed in a previous 2020 paper by Darryl Seligman himself. A few months later, Avi wrote a paper with Thiem Hoang, showing that heating by interstellar starlight would destroy hydrogen icebergs too quickly and not allow them to reach the solar system from their likely formation sites of giant molecular clouds.
https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-022-05687-w
Read Hoang and Loeb's response paper:
https://lweb.cfa.harvard.edu/~loeb/Hoang_Loeb_23.pdf
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
They’re Going to Destroy Science! Eric Weinstein and Brian Keating Part 2 of 2 (#302b)
They’re Going to Destroy Science! Eric Weinstein and Brian Keating Part 1 of 2 (#302a)
Freeman Dyson (#301)
What’s the Matter of Everything? Particle Physicist Suzie Sheehy on the INTO THE IMPOSSIBLE Podcast (#300)
Eric Weinstein & Dan Green: Can New Physics Be Tested? (#299)
Part 2 of 2: David Friedberg is All-In on Science (#298)
Part 1 of 2: David Friedberg is All-In on Science (#297)
Dan Green Physics is NOT In Crisis! (#296)
Aliens are NOT here! With Sarah Scoles (#295)
Aliens are Out There! Lisa Kaltenegger (#294)
Putting Einstein to the TEST: Jim Gates (#293)
Do We Live in a Mirror Universe? Oliver Philcox (#292)
This Book Sent Galileo To JAIL! (#291)
Is There A MIND Behind the Big Bang? Luke Barnes on Brian Keating’s INTO THE IMPOSSIBLE Podcast (#290)
SETI and Beyond: A discussion with Brian Keating, Paul Davies, Jim Benford and Mat Kaplan - Replay (#289)
The Problem With General Relativity with Prof. Brian Keating and Event Horizon Host John Michael Godier: Part 1 of 2 (#288)
The Year in Astronomy & Physics! (#287)
A Look Back on 2022 in Science With Brian Keating and Special Guest Eric Weinstein (#286)
What's Important for the 2nd Half of Your Life? James Altucher & Brian Keating Part 2 of 2 (#285)
Does Dark Matter Exist? Stacy McGaugh (#284)
Create your
podcast in
minutes
It is Free
Sasquatch Chronicles
The Confessionals
Radiolab
Sasquatch Odyssey
Science Friday