In this special anniversary episode of Waiting on the Trade, we’re looking back at the (roughly) 50 comics we’ve read so far and finally doing what the fans have demanded: Ranking all the stories against each other. This episode has arguments, updates, discussions of artistic merit, and yes, a “completely objective” ranking of every comic from every regular episode of the show, from best to worst.
The Ranking ScaleBecause Pat and I are us, we actually thought fairly hard about what our ranking scale should look like. Pat wanted a tier-based system, to be able to divide comics between tiers of quality more quickly, and I argued for an odd number of tiers, so completely average comics could land squarely in the middle tier.
When the dust settled, our ranking scale looked like this:
Pre-episode, we’d actually gone back and forth a couple times about whether to rank comics from best to worst within each tier. Day of, we decided that if we were going to go for it, we should go for it. So we ranked every comic from best to worst; the first comic in our A tier is the “best” comic we’ve read, and the last comic in our F tier is the “worst” comic we’ve read.
(In case the sarcasm hasn’t come through by now, we both feel that ranking these was tough and that our rankings are absolutely colored by our individual perceptions. Your rankings and feelings may vary, and we of course recognize that making any piece of art is hard! We’re not here to trash any comics or creators; we just wanted to have a bit of fun. Even in the comics in our F tier have their good bits.)
The Finalized RankingsWith that explanation of our system out of the way, here are the final rankings:
You can also view the rankings in spreadsheet form by clicking here. Do I feel slightly bad about pushing Pat into making DIE our top-ranked comic? No, I don’t. It’s that good.
A Special Thank YouAs we mentioned in the episode, doing this podcast has been a blast, and we’re very grateful to all of our guest hosts, who have come on to discuss these now-ranked stories with us. The rankings have nothing to do with the quality of our cohosts; all the people we have been lucky enough to have on the show are fantastic. (And we thank them for putting up with us.)
I’d also like to thank anyone who has listened to even one episode of the show. Hopefully, we discussed one of your favorite books, and you enjoyed the discussion. Making Waiting on the Trade is something I look forward to each month, and I hope you look forward to receiving it in your podcast feed.
New to the show? Waiting on the Trade is a comics book club podcast, run by two gents who don’t have time for monthly comics. If you’d like to get in touch with us, you can email us at WaitingOnTheTrade@gmail.com.
You can also find us on:
As always, thanks for listening!
They Called Us Enemy
Codename: Sailor V Vol. 1
Pulp
Doctor Strange: The Way of the Weird
The Sandman: Endless Nights
Geis: A Matter of Life and Death
Atomic Robo and Other Strangeness
Batman/Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles
Fables Vol. 1: Legends in Exile
Nancy Drew and the Hardy Boys: The Big Lie
The Unbeatable Squirrel Girl Beats Up the Marvel Universe
The One Hundred Nights of Hero
The Green Lantern Vol. 1
Barrier
Ghost Rider: The Last Stand
X-Men: God Loves, Man Kills
Blackbird Vol. 1
Superman/Batman: Supergirl
Batman: Hush
Wotakoi: Love Is Hard for Otaku Vol. 1
Create your
podcast in
minutes
It is Free
Merriam-Webster’s Word of the Day
Treasure Island by Robert Louis Stevenson
A Little Princess by Frances Hodgson Burnett
The Story of Mankind
Anne of Avonlea
Esquire Classic Podcast
The Adventures of Pinocchio by Carlo Collodi