With apologies for the pun, the Fifteenth Court of Appeals faces an “unprecedented” situation.
Unlike the other intermediate courts of appeal in Texas, the newly created Fifteenth Court of Appeals has no immediate predecessor. The Legislature gave it statewide jurisdiction over specific kinds of cases, as opposed to general jurisdiction over cases from a particular geographic area. As a result, that court does not start with an “inherited” body of precedent.
The Fifteenth Court thus faces a novel—and fundamental—question: what is its precedent?
This episode examines five sources of insight for answering that question: (1) English common law (as defined by a Texas statute dating back to the Republic); (2) “vertical” precedent, as described by a 2022 supreme court case; (3) federal practice about the Erie doctrine; (4) generally recognized conflicts-of-laws principles; and (5) historical examples from the 1840s, when the Supreme Court of the Republic of Texas confronted a similar problem with a lack of precedent.
Interview with Jury Consultant Jason Bloom -- How 2020 Shapes the Restart of Jury Trials
How is a monk like a veterinarian? The modern Constitution's protection of economic liberty
QAnon, Faces on Mars, and Joe Biden's Inauguration
Can Biden do that? The limits on policymaking by executive order
Can Donald Trump be impeached after he has left office?
Can President Trump pardon himself?
Showdown on Sixth Street: Governor v. Mayor on COVID-19 regulations
No, Texas Can't Secede: A Tale of the Supreme Court and the Confederate Treasury
The Spirit of 1876 - Why Rutherford Hayes Haunts the 2020 Election
Church and COVID - the Supreme Court blocks a gathering-size restriction
"Release the Kraken!" - the risks of Constitutional myth-making
Don't stand so close to the courts -- "standing" and why many election cases fail
Sir Walter Raleigh and President Trump's election lawsuits
Halloween Special - "Attack of the Zombie Statute!"
"Who's on First?" - Why it matters who is sued in election cases.
"Nice Ballot, Old Chap" - How do courts measure the "abridgement" of voting rights?
"Just Kidding?!" -- Can a State Legislature Replace the Popular Vote for President?
Cross-Examining God: Religion's Role in the Barrett Confirmation Hearings
Mark Your Calendar: Six Dates to Know for the 2020 Presidential Election Cycle
Advice and Consent: Can Justice Ginsburg be Replaced in 2020?
Create your
podcast in
minutes
It is Free
City Manager Unfiltered
Potencial Americano
The ASIC Podcast
The Chris Plante Show
Strict Scrutiny