Mad in America: Rethinking Mental Health
Health & Fitness:Mental Health
Welcome to MIA Reports, showcasing our independent and original journalism devoted to rethinking psychiatry. We take selected MIA Reports and provide them as audio articles. Click here for the text version of this and all of our MIA reports.
The Whistleblower and Penn: A Final Accounting of Study 352
Written by Peter Simons, read by James Moore, first published on Mad in America, December 29, 2019.
Although the general story of ghostwriting in trials of psychiatric drugs is now pretty well known, the details of the corruption in specific trials are still emerging into the public record, often a decade or more after the original sin of fraudulent publication. The latest study to finally see the full light of day is GlaxoSmithKline’s study 352.
Perhaps the most infamous ghostwritten study is GSK’s study 329, which, in a 2001 report published in the American Journal of Psychiatry, falsely touted paroxetine (Paxil) as an effective treatment for adolescent depression. The company paid over $3 billion in penalties for fraud.
That same year, study 352 made its first appearance in the research literature. That was when Charles Nemeroff, who in the years ahead would become the public face of research misconduct, “authored” an article on the efficacy of paroxetine for bipolar disorder. It has taken 18 years for the full story of that corruption to become known, the final chapter recently emerging when a large cache of study 352 documents—emails, memos, and other internal correspondence between the key players—was made public.
The documents reveal a web of corruption that went beyond the fraud of ghostwriting into the spinning of negative results into positive conclusions, and the abetting of that corruption by an editor of the scientific journal that published the article. The documents also reveal a whitewashing of the corruption by the University of Pennsylvania.
However, it was the publication of these documents that provided Jay Amsterdam, an investigator in the trial who turned whistleblower after he smelled a rat, with a chance to say “case closed.” Amsterdam and Leemon McHenry have now published two articles that provide a step-by-step deconstruction of the study—the ghostwriting, the spinning of results, the betrayal of public trust.
Here is the story of that whistleblowing.
Can Psychosocial Disability Decolonize Mental Health? A Conversation with Luis Arroyo and Justin Karter
Sarah Fay - Cured: A Memoir
Sharon Lambert and Naoise Ó Caoilte - Mental Health Podcasts: A Force for Good in a Contested Field
James Greenblatt - 'We Have a Neck' - The Links Between Body and Brain
Nandita Chaudhary - Challenging Western-Centric Child Psychology
Mia Berrin - Embodying Emotional Taboos: Musicians and Mental Health
David Edward Walker - Oppressive Mental Health Practices - For Native People, the Past is Present
Chris Bullard - The Sound Mind Festival
Chris van Tulleken - Ultra-Processed People: Why Do We All Eat Stuff That Isn't Food and Why Can't We Stop?
David Carmichael - The Antidepressant Safety Tour
Tanya Frank - Zig Zag Boy: My Family's Struggles With Broken Mental Healthcare
Pata Suyemoto - Centering Racial Justice and Community in Mental Health Advocacy and Suicide Prevention
Camille Robcis - Uncovering Radical Psychiatry and Institutional Psychotherapy in Postwar France
Erick Turner - Making a Silk Purse Out of a Sow's Ear: How Publication Bias Threatens Research Integrity and Public Health
Adam Urato - Chemicals Have Consequences: Antidepressants and Pregnancy
Owen Whooley - Psychiatry's Cycle of Ignorance and Reinvention
Project LETS: Building Peer-Led Mental Health Alternatives on Campus
A Revolution Wobbles: Will Norway’s "Medication-Free” Hospital Survive?
Ten Years of Rocking the Boat - Reflecting on Mad in America's Mission and Work
Changing Narratives - Reflecting on Mad in America's Mission and Work
Create your
podcast in
minutes
It is Free
Good Mood Revolution
Mental Health Insights
MQ Open Mind
Speaking of Suicide
The Suicide Prevention Movement
Depression Talks Podcast