What does this second volume of “filler-arc ‘Gantz’ spinoff” have to convince us that it’s not just a tired cash-in? How about drama between teenage girls! It’s actually more appealing that I’m making it sound as the dynamics between the five girls who survived the first volume distinguish it a little from its parent series. So rather than have a diverse group of survivors who come together when faced with these unbelievable circumstances, we’ve got a team who is going to let petty drama drive them apart.
That’s the impression I’m getting from this volume as hero protagonist Kei, her bookish manga-loving friend Yoshiko, model and class idol Kimiko, professional idol Morishita, and blonde silent type Kaji fail to bond in the way you’d expect them to. It mainly comes down to the fact that Kei’s initiative in the training sessions that the two (handsome) young male Gantz survivors have set up impresses them. Which annoys Yoshiko and Morishita to no end, leading them to spread ugly rumors about Kei on a message board frequented by their classmates. Kaji doesn’t put too much stock in any of this, though. She’s got her hands full with an abusive father, a person who seems like the perfect subject to test out the power given to her by the Gantz suit.
The characters’ circumstances, personalities, and the drama that results from them aren’t particularly new. However, the definition given to the characters here at least helps them move beyond the one-dimensional ciphers they came off as in the first volume. I’m also intrigued by how Kei’s straightforward heroic persona is proving to be divisive amongst the group rather than the uniting force you’d expect it to be. It’s led us to a Gantz team that isn’t working together and I’m curious to see if it winds up having dire results for everyone in the next and final volume. A filler arc where teamwork fails and everyone dies at the end? That’d be novel if nothing else.
jason@glickscomicpicks.com
Comic Picks #260: Genshiken -- Second Season
Comic Picks #259: Letter 44
Comic Picks #258: Snowpiercer
Comic Picks #257: Black Panther by Christopher Priest
Comic Picks #256: Catching Up With Batman
Comic Picks #255: Parasyte
Comic Picks #254: Best of 2017
Comic Picks #253: Inuyashiki
Comic Picks #252: Secret Empire
Comic Picks #251: JLA by Grant Morrison
Comic Picks #250: Rachel Rising
Comic Picks #249: Baltimore
Comic Picks #248: Jeff Lemire -- Old Man Logan/Royal City
Comic Picks #247: Batman -- The Dark Knight: The Master Race
Comic Picks #246: Goodnight Punpun
Comic Picks #245: Inhumans vs. X-Men
Comic Picks #244: Alias/Jessica Jones
Comic Picks #243: Wolfsmund
Comic Picks #242: Guardians of the Galaxy by Bendis
Comic Picks #241: Ichi-F
Create your
podcast in
minutes
It is Free
Otaku’s Anonymous
Dinner with the Heelers - A Bluey Podcast
The One Piece Podcast
That One Piece Talk
Crunchyroll Presents: The Anime Effect