In this episode, Kelly recounts the chilling story of Amy St. Laurent, a young woman who vanished in 2001 after a night out. Amy's determination for a fulfilling life was evident until her abrupt disappearance following a night spent with Eric Rubright in Portland, post her breakup with boyfriend Richard.
Eric's dubious actions and testimony caught police attention, prompting Jeffrey Gorman, another person present that evening, to disclose crucial details under peer influence. Gorman corroborated Eric's version of events, intensifying the search for Amy despite inconclusive polygraph results, leaving her family in anguish.
Kelly covers the unsettling events surrounding Amy's vanishing, implicating Russ - who offered Amy a ride from a discomforting party - as a prime suspect. Russ's evasive demeanor, refusal of a polygraph, and inconsistencies in his roommates' statements unveiled a harrowing narrative involving assault, drugging, and a fatal shooting. Russ's erratic behavior, confession to his mother, subsequent arrest, and a 60-year prison sentence ultimately served justice, despite his mother's efforts to retract her statement, emphasizing the tragic injustice Amy endured.
Timestamps:
0:03:41 Amy's High School and College Dreams
0:06:46 Amy's Night Out in 2001
0:10:06 Eric Rubright's Confusion and Concern
0:17:56 Police Press Conference and Investigation
0:20:50 Tip Line and Jeffrey "Russ" Gorman's Call
0:23:32 Uncomfortable Departure
0:24:37 Polygraph Decline
0:26:51 Suspicious Details
0:28:32 Applying Pressure
0:30:20 Suspicious Detail
0:32:16 Search Initiates
0:35:20 Tool Borrowing
0:37:33 Cadaver Dog Discovery
0:43:03 Disturbing Confession
0:46:38 Compelled Testimony
0:48:37 Sentencing Reaction
Check out Factor! This holiday season, you might be looking for nutritious, convenient meals to keep you energized on jam-packed days. Factor, America’s #1 Ready-To-Eat Meal Delivery Service, can help you fuel up fast for breakfast, lunch, and dinner with chef-prepared, dietitian-approved ready-to-eat meals delivered straight to your door. You’ll save time, eat well, and stay on track with your healthy lifestyle while tackling all your holiday to- dos.
Click HERE for 50% off by using the code unspeakable50
view more
Eric's dubious actions and testimony caught police attention, prompting Jeffrey Gorman, another person present that evening, to disclose crucial details under peer influence. Gorman corroborated Eric's version of events, intensifying the search for Amy despite inconclusive polygraph results, leaving her family in anguish.
Kelly covers the unsettling events surrounding Amy's vanishing, implicating Russ - who offered Amy a ride from a discomforting party - as a prime suspect. Russ's evasive demeanor, refusal of a polygraph, and inconsistencies in his roommates' statements unveiled a harrowing narrative involving assault, drugging, and a fatal shooting. Russ's erratic behavior, confession to his mother, subsequent arrest, and a 60-year prison sentence ultimately served justice, despite his mother's efforts to retract her statement, emphasizing the tragic injustice Amy endured.
Timestamps:
0:03:41 Amy's High School and College Dreams
0:06:46 Amy's Night Out in 2001
0:10:06 Eric Rubright's Confusion and Concern
0:17:56 Police Press Conference and Investigation
0:20:50 Tip Line and Jeffrey "Russ" Gorman's Call
0:23:32 Uncomfortable Departure
0:24:37 Polygraph Decline
0:26:51 Suspicious Details
0:28:32 Applying Pressure
0:30:20 Suspicious Detail
0:32:16 Search Initiates
0:35:20 Tool Borrowing
0:37:33 Cadaver Dog Discovery
0:43:03 Disturbing Confession
0:46:38 Compelled Testimony
0:48:37 Sentencing Reaction
Check out Factor! This holiday season, you might be looking for nutritious, convenient meals to keep you energized on jam-packed days. Factor, America’s #1 Ready-To-Eat Meal Delivery Service, can help you fuel up fast for breakfast, lunch, and dinner with chef-prepared, dietitian-approved ready-to-eat meals delivered straight to your door. You’ll save time, eat well, and stay on track with your healthy lifestyle while tackling all your holiday to- dos.
Click HERE for 50% off by using the code unspeakable50
More Episodes
The Chef of Portland
2025-11-19
2025-11-19
DTL - Part 3: Brazen Attack
2025-11-17
2025-11-17
DTL - Part 2: Eye of the Storm
2025-11-10
2025-11-10
DTL - Part 1: Inception of Evil
2025-11-03
2025-11-03
Five Days
2025-10-29
2025-10-29
Conspiring To Murder
2025-10-22
2025-10-22
The Notorious Kehoe Family
2025-10-15
2025-10-15
Serial Killer: John Joubert Part 2
2025-10-08
2025-10-08
Serial Killer: John Joubert
2025-09-30
2025-09-30
Get this podcast on your
phone, FREE
