My Worst Investment Ever Podcast
Business:Investing
BIO: Mark Neuman is the CIO and founder of Constraint Capital. He is a CFA charterholder and creator of the ESG orphans index.
STORY: Mark talks about constrained capital, ESG orphans, and his work around it.
LEARNING: We can’t get to the future of energy without present energy. To win the renewable energy fight, we must put facts above feelings.
“We can’t get to the future of energy without present energy.”Mark Neuman
Guest profile
Mark Neuman is the CIO and founder of Constraint Capital. He is a CFA charter holder and creator of the ESG orphans index. He’s a 30-year Wall Street veteran and former global equity derivatives trader with Merrill Lynch, Susquehanna, Jones Trading, and Bay Crest partners. He’s a former event-driven hedge fund partner. In his recent investment project, he spent 1,000 hours of deep dive into all things ESG over the past six years. His goal is to deliver truth in ESG to protect and help investors make informed decisions with measurable results when understanding risk and reward.
In today’s episode, Mark talks about constrained capital, ESG orphans, and the work he is doing around it.
Constraints on capitalAccording to Mark, constraints on capital is a pattern that exists in the market based on policy, investment themes, and philosophies. Most recently, ESG (Environmental, Social, Governance) has been the most prominent example of constraints on capital. Constraints on capital cause misallocation and malinvestment. In general, they are starving specific industries and flooding others.
For example, in ESG, constraints were heavily implemented on fossil fuels, nuclear energy, weapons, alcohol, tobacco, and gambling. Basically, ESG said those were bad. On the other side, they chose certain winners that were apparently good in ESG, leading to the misallocation of capital because, though these winners are considered great, they still have a considerable carbon footprint.
Ultimately, the constraints push capital to one place and starve capital to another. The ESG orphans are the six sectors, fossil fuel, nuclear energy, weapons, alcohol, tobacco, and gambling, that were routinely excluded. As they’re being cut off from capital, the value of their stocks falls.
Looming reversal flows for ESG orphansIn the last decade up through 2021, the Info-Tech space in the S&P 500 grew from 18% weighting to 36%. On the other hand, the energy sector shrunk from about 10% to 2.5% and became so cheap within the same decade. Mark indicates that we’ll see a reversion over a more extended period. As ESG gets called out, we’ll see reversal flows that will return to those excluded names.
Put facts above feelingsMark insists he’s not anti-ESG; he’s simply anti the ESG bubble as an investor and a CFA charterholder. He says there’s significant value in many of these companies that have been discarded. We simply need a different energy plan. While Mark agrees we need to find a replacement for fossil energy, he believes that we can’t get to the future of energy without present energy.
Therefore, it makes no sense to starve Exxon Mobil, for example, instead of leaning on it to lead the renewable energy change. Mark thinks people putting feelings above facts on some level is a troubling aspect of ESG.
Mark has been doing a lot of ESG consulting, working with companies to help them understand the risks. If certain companies have been classified by ESG as medium risk or low risk, Mark wants to kick the tires and turn it over. He’s helping companies do their own due diligence and dig into what their ESG analysis really means. Mark’s passion is ensuring people understand risk and reward and are not misled by ESG, saying, “Everybody wins, nobody loses, it’s costless, and we’re all benefiting.” That sounds too good to be true for him.
[spp-transcript]
Connect with Mark Neuman
Laurens Swinkels – Stay Liquid Even When Investing Long-Term
Spencer Jakab – Don’t Take Investment Tips from People
Charles Rotblut – Realize When You’re Lucky and Walk Away
Arjun Murti – You’ve Got to Get Out of the Battle At Some Point
ISMS 25: Larry Swedroe – Admit Your Mistakes and Don’t Listen to Fake Experts
Steven Wilkinson – Your Success Is 100% Dependent on You
Shawn O'Malley – Geopolitics Can Take Your Investment to Zero
Peter Saddington – I Got Fired From My Own Company
Neville Medhora – Hot Stock Tips Are Generally Unreliable
Jack Farley – Don’t Play in Markets You Don’t Know
Carter Malloy – Valuation Is Not a Reason to Invest
ISMS 24: Larry Swedroe – Confusing Skill and Luck Can Stop You From Investing Wisely
Gisela Hausmann – Encourage and Appreciate Your Employees’ Creativity
Connor Steinbrook – Do Due Diligence Before Visiting a Real Estate Property
Zachary Resnick – Invest in People Not Just Ideas
Chris Mamula – Take Responsibility for Your Financial Situation
Michael Howell – Liquidity Is the Main Driver of Asset Markets
Brady Slack – What to Look For in a Coach or Mentor
Richard Lawrence – Avoid the Stock That’s the Hype of the Day
Vineer Bhansali – You Create Real Value by Being Different
Create your
podcast in
minutes
It is Free
The emPOWERed Half Hour
U.S Property Podcast
Aligned Money Show
Dubai Property Podcast
The Ramsey Show
The Clark Howard Podcast