In this bonus episode, our host and CEO Renaud is joined by our product reliability and durability expert, Andrew Amirnovin, to talk about the bad news for Apple that their much-hyped Vision Pro headset is cracking just weeks after being released to the public. They explore the durability problems rearing their heads only a month or so into the product's general release in early February 2024, based on information found in online news articles and videos.
Show Sections
00:00 - Introduction, what is the Vision Pro?
Apple's Vision Pro headset is an incredibly well-received augmented reality headset that earned rave reviews worldwide. It took more than 10 years to develop and is one of the most groundbreaking Apple products released in recent years.
02:29 - Uh-oh, cracks to the headset!
The external plastic layer, like a visor, is cracking in a straight line from the nose to the forehead on some models even though the customer didn't do anything like drop them. We don't know the percentage, so it's hard to ascertain what pattern there is, but these unsightly defects are not welcome in a device that costs over $3000+.
04:04 - How would an engineer start diagnosing this case?
Environmental or transportation conditions may cause a defect like this or it could even be the packaging placing some kind of stress on the wrong part of the visor that eventually results in the crack developing. It is fair to say that the plastic seems fragile.
Apple should accept field returns from customers and do a root cause analysis to identify the defect and its cause and then implement a corrective action plan.
06:40 - Is the return or repair policy straightforward? What should Apple customers do if they're affected?
Apple may need to clarify its returns or repair policy, as some customers have reported receiving different responses from Apple with some stores offering to repair or replace, and some refusing to take responsibility. With visor repairs costing $800, it seems sensible to at least invest in an AppleCare extended warranty for the device to reduce potential repair costs.
08:48 - Is it likely Apple's engineers missed this issue and never saw it during product testing and development?
It's hard to say, but was the visor that cracks added after most development and testing was done maybe for some reason? If so it may not have been tested (as much). If Apple doesn't fix this, and fast, it could damage their brand as this is such a high-profile release. The situation is similar to the problems they had with the Macbook 'Butterfly' keyboards in 2015/2016 which they replaced by returning to a scissor mechanism they then named the 'Magic' keyboard, although in those cases Apple replaced the defective keyboard (and sometimes added a new battery) for free.
11:29 - We all know that an iPhone is likely to suffer damage when dropped from 6ft, should we be surprised that the Vision Pro seems similarly fragile?
The Vision Pro does not seem very durable, the same as the iPhone. The majority of users put their iPhones in a protective case for exactly this reason.
An acceptable drop height for a mobile phone to withstand damage is about 1M, not 6ft. However the Vision Pro is meant to be worn on the face and is very front-heavy, so if it slips, it will likely fall from around 6ft. There is no protective case for the Vision Pro when it is in use unlike for phones, therefore, should it be durable enough to survive such a drop, especially for its price?
13:27 - Wrapping up.
Related content...
Get in touch with us
What’s The ’Cradle To Cradle’ Product Design Concept?
Could War In Ukraine Affect Chinese Supply Chains?
6 Phases Of The Industrial Design Process (Feat. Andy Bartlett)
BONUS: Covid Situation in China (24 Feb 2022)
Building Rapport With Suppliers - Sourcing from China (Part 5)
The Long-Term Costs of Poor Quality & Reliability (feat. Clive Greenwood & Andrew Amirnovin)
All About Industrial Design (feat. Andy Bartlett)
Chinese Or Western Model Manufacturer. Which To Use In China?
Risks You Face When Skipping New Product Introduction Steps (feat. Andrew Amirnovin)
What Makes An Appropriate NNN Agreement?
Use final inspections to verify order quality BEFORE shipment - Sourcing from China (Part 4)
Looking Back At 2021’s Key Stories For Importers From China
The 3 Elements Your Factory Needs To Get Right For Good Manufacturing Performance (feat. Andrew Amirnovin)
6 E-commerce Trends - With A Focus On Amazon (feat. Marshall Taplits)
Project management & checking quality early in production - Sourcing from China (Part 3)
Preparing For Chinese New Year 2022 Disruption
What Are The Main Risks To Your Product IP?
The Importance Of Setting Up A Good Reliability Testing Plan (feat. Andrew Amirnovin)
Why Are US Logistics Under So Much Strain? + E-commerce Challenges (feat. Marshall Taplits)
How design authority leads to product safety liability (feat. Clive Greenwood & Andrew Wilson)
Create your
podcast in
minutes
It is Free
The Commercial Edge: Unleash the Power of People
The emPOWERed Half Hour
Aligned Money Show
Gorse Culture PODcast : The H.R. Detective Agency!
HCI Leadership Revolution
The Ramsey Show
Planet Money