A recent article in The Guardian described the “death spiral” looming for public transit in the United States. Country-wide, the pandemic has resulted in a 90% drop in ridership. This has led to cuts in services—which means even less ridership—and higher fares to make up for lost revenue. Higher fares lead to fewer riders…which means more higher fares, more cuts in services, or both. And so on. You see where this is going.
To save public transit, Congress may have to fill a $32 billion funding gap...but no funding package currently exists. Transportation advocates also warn that cuts in services exacerbate a “mobility crisis” that already existed for our cities’ most vulnerable people.
This article prompted a lively conversation on this week’s episode of Upzoned, with host Abby Kinney—an urban planner in Kansas City—and cohost Chuck Marohn, president of Strong Towns. Abby and Chuck discuss why the mortal danger facing public transit was always going to be an option when you overlay a dysfunctional transportation system on a dysfunctional land-use pattern, why public transit is a long-term investment in people, and how the U.S. subsidizes automobiles too. They also discuss whether making the “compassionate argument” may unintentionally undermine transit advocates’ case for public transportation.
Additional Show NotesPublic transit faces 'death spiral' without $32bn injection from Congress, by Miranda Bryant
Abby Kinney (Twitter)
Charles Marohn (Twitter)
Gould Evans Studio for City Design
Theme Music by Kemet the Phantom (Soundcloud)
Some recent Strong Towns articles on public transit
“The Only Thing More Expensive Than Saving Transit is Not Saving Transit,” by Daniel Herriges
“In Transportation Costs, ‘It's the System, Stupid,’” by Daniel Herriges
“What the Left Gets Wrong about Public Transportation” (Podcast)
“Transit’s Chicken & Egg Fallacy,” by Chuck Marohn
“Why Development-Oriented Transit is better than Transit-Oriented Development,” by Rachel Quednau
Accessory Dwelling Units Rock. But Should States Be Overriding Cities' Laws About Building Them?
Can Cities Like St. Louis Get Financially Stronger by Merging with Richer Places?
Can a Big City Solve a Big Housing Shortage Incrementally?
Is the Household Garage America's Favorite Room or America's Worst Mistake?
Should Single-Family Neighborhoods Be Able to Buy Their Way out of Building More Housing?
What the Explosion of the Dollar Store Says About the State of Our Cities
Would you move to a new city for $10,000?
Five Gifts For the Strong Towns Advocate in Your Life (or Just For Yourself)
Amazon HQ2: Really, New York?
Can Walmart Restore the Town Centers It Helped to Kill?
Do You Really Have to Wear a Bike Helmet?
When it Comes to Housing, Do Millennials Have a Different American Dream?
Is Landlord Greed Responsible for Vacant Storefronts in NYC?
Opportunity Zones, But for Whom?
Failure and the Scientific Method
House Flipping in the Rust Belt
Big box stores think their tax bills should be lower. Are they right?
Dams and Reservoirs Won't Save Us
Create your
podcast in
minutes
It is Free
The emPOWERed Half Hour
Social Dallas Podcast
Change Church Podcast
Six Degrees with Kevin Bacon
Nonprofits Are Messy: Lessons in Leadership | Fundraising | Board Development | Communications
System Catalysts