In this Christmas-themed episode Jeff and Dave take a break from the Aeneid to look at Luke's Gospel, chapter 2:1-5, and the puzzling census of Quirinius. Drawing from half a dozen scholarly articles on the subject, we try to puzzle out the four major objections to Luke's reliability as a historian on the topic of the census:
“1. Apart from the gospel, history knows nothing of a general Imperial census in the time of Augustus.
2. There could have been no Roman census in Palestine during the time of Herod the Great, a rex socius.
3. Such a census at such a time could not have been carried out by Quirinius, for he was not governor in Syria then, nor till 10 years later, when he did make a census which gave rise to a revolt under Judas of Galilee.
4. Under a Roman census it would not have been necessary for Joseph to go to Bethlehem, or for Mary to accompany him.” - Alexander Balmain Bruce, D.D. (from Epxositor's Greek New Testament, W. Robertson Nicoll, 1897; p. 470)
Can each of these objections be met? Was Publius Sulpicius Quirinius gov. of Syria twice, before the death of Herod the Great and again in 6-7 A.D. for the census mentioned in Acts 5? What about inscriptional evidence? Is Luke reliable as a historian?
You won't want to miss this thorough look at the subject, complete with some excellent intro. and outro. music generously provided by guitar wizard extraordinaire Jeff Scheetz.
Hey, I’ma be Liver Now: Aeschylus’ Prometheus Bound, Part II (Ad Navseam, Episode 131)
We Didn’t Steal the Fire: Aeschylus’ Prometheus Bound, Part I (Ad Navseam, Episode 130)
Giving Goliath his Due: Mycenaeans and Philistines, Part II (Ad Navseam, Episode 129)
Giving Goliath his Due: Mycenaeans and Philistines, Part I (Ad Navseam, Episode 128)
Do the Rite Thing: The Homeric Hymn to Demeter, Part II (Ad Navseam, Episode 127)
No Pain, No Grain: The Homeric Hymn to Demeter, Part I (Ad Navseam, Episode 126)
Whoa, Milo, Come on, Come On, Let’s Go: The Greatest Ancient Athlete (Ad Navseam, Episode 125)
Use Your Allusion II: Classics in Pop Music (Ad Navseam, Episode 124)
Gildy as Charged: Arachne and Midas in two More Ovidian Vignettes (Ad Navseam, Episode 123)
The Riddle of the Labyrinth: A Conversation with Margolit Fox (Ad Navseam, Episode 122)
Loading the Canons: The Art of Classical Rhetoric (Ad Navseam, Episode 121)
Here Comes the Rage Again: Aeneid XII, Part 2 (Ad Navseam, Episode 120)
Duel Unto Others: Aeneid XII, Part 1 (Ad Navseam, Episode 119)
Tarzan and Tradition: Classical Myth in Popular Literature II (Ad Navseam, Episode 118)
Tarzan and Tradition: Classical Myth in Popular Literature I (Ad Navseam, Episode 117)
A Thrilla with Camilla: Aeneid XI, Part 2 (Ad Navseam, Episode 116)
With Pallas toward None: Aeneid XI, Part 1 (Ad Navseam, Episode 115)
Male Pattern Baldric: Aeneid X, Part 2 (Ad Navseam, Episode 114)
All’s Hair in Love and War! Aeneid X, Part 1 (Ad Navseam, Episode 113)
Translating Samuel Rutherford’s Examen Arminianismi (Ad Navseam, Episode 112)
Create your
podcast in
minutes
It is Free
LifeBlood
Navigating Life After 40
Teaching Learning Leading K-12
The Jordan B. Peterson Podcast
The Mel Robbins Podcast